Talk:Hr 4437

It is so sad that a person that espouses the word of the wise can be so ignorant of the facts. Shame on you!! Shame on all individuals that are unwilling to research and communicate with us that have lived through LEGAL immigration and then you express an opinion that is hate against the legal immigrant. Shame on you for pushing your own agenda. SHAME ON YOU!!! Just goes to show the world that you are wrong, again! I'm a legal immigrant. I have the permission of the American Government to be here. Someone you SLAP IN MY FACE by not supporting HR4437. I broke no LAW to enter this country. I have done those jobs you claim no American will do so that as to have a reason why we should let the ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS come here. Your ignorance should place you back into your mother’s womb so you could start life over. I'm positive you aren't even aware that you support the wrong cause. My family and I had to wait many years to get into the U. S. A. Now, after working three and four jobs at the same time, I have put myself through college and have four college degrees including a PhD. Unfortunately, the self-righteous will never understand. Individuals, like yourself, completely misconstrue the facts and lie to the general public especially those that are poorly educated; specifically the illegals you support. You should be ashamed of your actions and I dare you to ever try to converse coherently to the LEGAL IMMIGRANTS of the AMERICA about this topic without looking as uneducated as you show yourself to be. You are not only foolish but I believe you can't explain your position without insulting the GREAT LEGAL IMMIGRANTS of America. WELL educated and willing to take the ILLEGALS AND SEND THEM BACK TO WAIT IN LINE AS WE LEGALS HAVE HAD TO DO!!

DumbFu**k you obviously dont know what you are talking about. I say that we let illegals stay they do no harm. They are the ones who picked the fruit that you eat. SO Fu*k you. As*hole

There is a non-copyright-infringing (I hope), less controversial (though far from perfect) article at H.R. 4437. I believe that Hr 4437 should redirect to that article.

This is not a place to discuss HR 4437, but the neutrality of the article. I'm placing it in form of a rewrite, please do not edit about while I am going about this. blu_rav3 21:27, 28 March 2006 (UTC)

I am against HR 4437, but I do believe another form of legislation that provides a fair way for illegals to obtain residency status would be better.

For example, McCain's proposal includes a guest worker visa (H-5A). Employers of H-5As may apply for their workers to change to permanent residency status for workers who have maintained four years of cumulative H-5A status.

Illegals who currently reside in the states may obtain an H-5B visa. McCain's proposal does not criminalize illegals.

I think this makes more sense.

why does this article exist?
there is already a better written article w/ fewer POV issues at H.R. 4437