Talk:Hush (2016 short film)

Inspiration is not a crime
At present, this article falls outside the scope of WikiProject Crime. While this article alleges the writer and director of the film drew inspiration from a real crime it does not explain what that inspiration was nor explain how the film is connected to that crime. Applying the guideline that articles must be written, a corollary of that essay is that the existing content of an article needs to demonstrate how the article concerned is within the scope of relevant WikiProjects. Inspiration is not a crime, even if it is taken from a real crime. If the film actually depicts crime, real or inspirational re-enactment, then the article needs to explain how the film does this, in some way. Adding a WikiProject because the editor knows something about the subject of an article, without stating it in the article and without providing the source of that statement or knowledge could be seen as original research or editorializing. In other words, if you see the film and think it is about crime, that is not sufficient to include the Wikipedia article in WikiProject Crime, without supporting evidence. - Cameron Dewe (talk) 23:22, 28 October 2022 (UTC)