Talk:Ickenham Lodge

The Lodge was founded by Brigadier Edwin Flavell, subject of a Wiki page, who was a Commander under Field Marshall Montgomery and the lodge entry will contain reference to him. In this regard,and some others, the lodge is noteworthy. Flavell lived in Ickenham.


 * The issue is not that the Lodge isn't notworthy, it's that the article needs to comply with the policy WP:Notability. That is, you need to demonstrate that people not immediately involved with the topic (i.e. people outside of Masonry, such as academics, journalists, etc) have examined this issue and written on the topic.


 * Separate from that, there's the issue that the article is currently a blur of numbers and Masonry terms, it's not yet accessible or helpful to a non-expert on the topic, so you'll need to address that issue by writing without any assumption of prior familiarity from the reader. MatthewVanitas (talk) 17:08, 2 July 2013 (UTC)

Copyright violation?
I suspect that the text of this article was simply cut and pasted directly from the one source that is cited (Hawley, John G: "65 Years On. The History of Ickenham Lodge No. 5770"). Is this the case? If so, then we have a WP:COPYVIO issue, and this article needs to either be majorly re-written or deleted (given the notability concerns raised above, I would lean towards deletion... but I want to give others a chance to fix the problem before I act on that.) Blueboar (talk) 12:06, 25 March 2017 (UTC)