Talk:Iveta Mukuchyan/GA1

GA Review
The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.''

Reviewer: Cartoon network freak (talk · contribs) 11:39, 13 December 2017 (UTC)

General

 * There are some really basic grammar issues throughout the article. I advise you make a request for the article to be copy-edited. However, this shouldn't discourage you from altogether trying to improve articles on here. You're doing a fantastic job in contributing to Armenia-related articles, but everything just needs somewhat fine-tuning. Cartoon network freak (talk) 12:27, 17 December 2017 (UTC)

Lead

 * for the fourth season of talent competition → for the fourth season of talent competition
 * In the same year she was named "Sexiest Armenian" → This is not a notable fact for a lead
 * In 2016, she also made → In the same year, she also made
 * Overall, the lead seems very short and it could contain much more information to cover the entire body of the article (take this length here as an expample for how long a lead section should be at least).

Infobox

 * You need to revise the ALT of the image to something like: "A shot of Mukuchyan with a black jacket, holding a microphone in her hand."
 * Songwriter and composer are the same thing; remove composer

Early life

 * 1986. She went to kindergarten in Yerevan → where she also went to kindergarten.
 * She went to school in Germany and from 1998 to 2006, she attended the Catholic Sankt-Ansgar-Schule in Hamburg → This was followed by Mukuchyan attending school in the country, with her later attending the Catholic Sankt-Ansgar-Schule in Hamburg from 1998 to 2006.
 * Along with attending school Iveta worked in a cafe as a waiter. → As a part-time job, she worked as a waiter in a café.
 * despite all the difficulties she had → despite alleged difficulties.
 * started studying jazz-vocal → what is "jazz-vocal"? I think I know what you mean, but that has another name, I think.
 * She has a sister, Marianna, who is a stylist → Her sister, Marianna, works as a stylist.

Career

 * competition Hay Superstar (Armenian version of the Pop Idol), → competition Hay Superstar, the Armenian version of Pop Idol,
 * She features in → She was also featured
 * the French track → the French language track
 * depute studio album → I think you mean "debut studio album"
 * Amalgame → you need to capitalize the album's name to Amalgame
 * released on 1 January 2010 → the album's release date is irrelevant in an article about Iveta; add the release year in brackets after Amalgame.
 * The following year, Iveta → always use peoples' last name
 * As I'm continuing, I see clipped short sentences, unreliable sources (e.g. Facebook), lots of fancruft, unformatted links and poor grammar. This is why I chose to stop my review here. Please see "Outcome".

Outcome

 * I've reviewed a select few sections, but as you can see, there are a substantial amount of basic errors with lack of referencing, and when there are references for something, it's usually an unreliable, or primary reference. However, PLEASE do not be discouraged. I think the first step would be to request the article be copy-edited as I mentioned above, and then even request someone to help you improve the article (however, I'd discourage asking me as I'd quite like to re-review this when it's been worked on, and if I've worked on it, I can't review it!) Best of luck, Cartoon network freak (talk) 12:27, 17 December 2017 (UTC)