Talk:James Giles (painter)

Still Underlinked?
I added a link to this page from Haddo House since it was an external link at the time. Aside from category pages and a cemetary list, this is now linked to from 3 pages -- all of the pages that showed up in the context search in the template. Is that enough to remove it? I'll do so in a few days if there's no objection.
 * Oh yeah, I said I'd do that, huh? Done. (forgot to sign my post up there too) &mdash;BlackTerror 13:59, 17 May 2007 (UTC)

POV issues?
This article has been on Cleanup since April stating that the last paragraph is biased and pov. Such analysis needs to be sourced. I've moved it here as a record.

''In his art, Giles possessed an adaptability in both style and treatment of landscape, which reveals itself in a number of aspects: the freedom of the early Italian sketches; the classical grandeur of the later Italianate landscapes; the romanticism of the Scottish landscape; the interrelationship of architecture and its surroundings; ideas about the place of humanity in the landscape and the occurrence of native animals in their natural habitat. All of these aspects have a common constituent in the artist’s professed ethos of taking his inspiration from detailed observation, directly from nature. It is his breadth and variety as a landscape painter, coupled with his devotion to detailed study from nature, that should earn James Giles his niche in the history of Scottish art.'' --Lendorien (talk) 16:44, 20 January 2008 (UTC)