Talk:Jean Harpedenne II

Montaigu? Coat of Arms?
Srnec and Newm30:

I only added the text today, removed a few minutes ago by Srnec, because it seemed to be supported by the Coat of Arms shown in the article, placed there in the first few days of you two creating and editing this article. I have no personal feeling on this item, other than a desire to see that the right wording (which the two of you are in a much better position to discuss) should be in the article.

The coat of arms in the article clearly states that they are the "Arms of Harpedenne, lords of Montaigu and Belleville".

These Coat of Arms clearly incorporate the Coat of Arms for the adjacent (27 km) Montaigu, as shown at the Montaigu, Vendée article.

Is the text under the arms image, saying that the Harpedennes were "lords of Montaigu and Belleville" correct, in which case it is legitimate to include it in the body of the article? Is the text under the arms image incorrect, and the mention of Montaigu should be removed everywhere from the article? Thanks for looking at this. Jmg38 (talk) 06:04, 15 April 2020 (UTC)


 * I assume the caption of the coat of arms was correct. But saying that this coat of arms was borne by the Harpedennes of Montaigue does not mean that Jean II was such. I have removed the coat of arms until we can verify that it was the personal arms of Jean II. Srnec (talk) 13:38, 15 April 2020 (UTC)