Talk:Jimmy Hotz

Which are primary sources
Which refs are you objecting to? A few dead links need to be removed or adjusted also, but which refs are you concerned about that are tied to the subject? There are two or three Youtube videos that should be removed because they are promotional. Thank you. Hardyplants (talk) 06:54, 10 April 2020 (UTC)
 * I moved this from my talk page because it belongs here. Let me do the review of each source to make my case. Walter Görlitz (talk) 21:33, 10 April 2020 (UTC)
 * Here's my review:
 * I'll start with the exiting refs.
 * {| class="wikitable"

! ref !! Class
 * || author: CRAIG ANDERTON, online mag. Probably a RS
 * || author: Mard Naman, online mag. Probably a RS
 * || author: Mard Naman, online mag. Passing mention of subject. Probably a RS
 * || author: Mard Naman, online mag. Passing mention of subject. Probably a RS
 * || Discogs. Not a RS.
 * || author: Karen Moltenbrey, online copy of mag. Interview with Hotz. Probably a RS, but relies heavily on primary.
 * || Eight-minute clip that is a copyvio. Not sure what it's supporting, it has been removed.
 * || Uploaded by Hotz777. Either a primary source or a copy vio.
 * || Primary source as Hotz is as one of three writers.
 * || Dead link
 * || Primary source
 * || No author. Not a RS.
 * || 404 error, but patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * || Primary source. patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * || Primary source. patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * || No author. Probably not a RS.
 * US Patent No. 5,099,738, US Patent & Trademark Office, Patent Full Text and Image Database. || Primary source. patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * US Patent No. 5,502,274, US Patent & Trademark Office, Patent Full Text and Image Database. || Primary source. patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * US Patent No. 5,619,003, US Patent European Patent No. EP 0452347 B1, Google Patents || Primary source. patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * || RS.
 * || Blog. Not a RS. Considered as opinion by the community.
 * || Blog. Not a RS.
 * Raised by Wolves: The Story of Christian Rock & Roll p.140 (Thompson 2000) || Author: Thompson. RS.
 * https://www.discogs.com/Jimmy-Hotz-The-Gates-Of-Time/release/4933379 || Discogs. Not a RS.
 * || Primary source, but in this case, RS, but Hotz is not listed!
 * || Reliable, secondary source.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * }
 * So we have 29 unique sources. 28 after the copy vio was removed. 11 are primary sources and the discog entries are poor. That's a good percentage of the refs. What's you're take? Walter Görlitz (talk) 22:40, 10 April 2020 (UTC)
 * || No author. Probably not a RS.
 * US Patent No. 5,099,738, US Patent & Trademark Office, Patent Full Text and Image Database. || Primary source. patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * US Patent No. 5,502,274, US Patent & Trademark Office, Patent Full Text and Image Database. || Primary source. patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * US Patent No. 5,619,003, US Patent European Patent No. EP 0452347 B1, Google Patents || Primary source. patents are primary sources by the author of the patent.
 * || RS.
 * || Blog. Not a RS. Considered as opinion by the community.
 * || Blog. Not a RS.
 * Raised by Wolves: The Story of Christian Rock & Roll p.140 (Thompson 2000) || Author: Thompson. RS.
 * https://www.discogs.com/Jimmy-Hotz-The-Gates-Of-Time/release/4933379 || Discogs. Not a RS.
 * || Primary source, but in this case, RS, but Hotz is not listed!
 * || Reliable, secondary source.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * }
 * So we have 29 unique sources. 28 after the copy vio was removed. 11 are primary sources and the discog entries are poor. That's a good percentage of the refs. What's you're take? Walter Görlitz (talk) 22:40, 10 April 2020 (UTC)
 * https://www.discogs.com/Jimmy-Hotz-The-Gates-Of-Time/release/4933379 || Discogs. Not a RS.
 * || Primary source, but in this case, RS, but Hotz is not listed!
 * || Reliable, secondary source.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * }
 * So we have 29 unique sources. 28 after the copy vio was removed. 11 are primary sources and the discog entries are poor. That's a good percentage of the refs. What's you're take? Walter Görlitz (talk) 22:40, 10 April 2020 (UTC)
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * || RS, no mention of Hotz.
 * }
 * So we have 29 unique sources. 28 after the copy vio was removed. 11 are primary sources and the discog entries are poor. That's a good percentage of the refs. What's you're take? Walter Görlitz (talk) 22:40, 10 April 2020 (UTC)
 * So we have 29 unique sources. 28 after the copy vio was removed. 11 are primary sources and the discog entries are poor. That's a good percentage of the refs. What's you're take? Walter Görlitz (talk) 22:40, 10 April 2020 (UTC)