Talk:John Emmet Sheridan

Middle Name vs (Illustrator) as disambiguator
My problem with "Emmet" is simple: how many people know his middle name (or could identify it in a source) vs the number of people who know that this John Sheridan was an illustrator? (and was there some other illustrator that was confusing people?). When people discover this John Sheridan, it is because he is notable AS and illustrator, not because he's an Emmet. I think we've lost notability in favor of specificity. KevinCuddeback (talk) 22:09, 18 October 2017 (UTC)