Talk:Kalhor (tribe)

Ethnocentric edits by some users
Wikipedia is a free science-based encyclopedia, not a place to your ethnocentric goals. Please don't delete citations about Lurish identity of Kablhor people. Please pay attention and stop it.Shadegan (talk) 14:50, 1 February 2017 (UTC)

Im a kalhor we are 100 percent Kurdish tribe, so stop Masoodo6 14:47, 15 September 2018 (UTC) — Preceding unsigned comment added by Masoodo6 (talk • contribs)

Fully protected for two weeks
Both of you could easily have been blocked for edit-warring, but I'm protecting this instead. Both of you have now been warned and please note that 3RR is not a right, if you go back to reverting each other you might both be blocked. You need to work this out, perhaps at WP:DRN or through a WP:RFC. You also need to avoid commenting on each other. Also, please note WP:NOENG, "Citations to non-English reliable sources are allowed on the English Wikipedia. However, because this project is in English, English-language sources are preferred over non-English ones when available and of equal quality and relevance. As with sources in English, if a dispute arises involving a citation to a non-English source, editors may request that a quotation of relevant portions of the original source be provided, either in text, in a footnote, or on the article talk page." What that doesn't mention and I think is important is that citations should include an English translation of the citation. Doug Weller talk 12:34, 2 February 2017 (UTC)

that user claimed a false identity (lurish) for that tribe by primary sources. In Persian wikipedia admins [//fa.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=ایل_کلهر&action=history protected that page] after rolling back his edits. Then he started to do vandalism in other languages. For translating sources i can do and also you can use google translate. --–  Hossein Iran  « talk »  08:33, 3 February 2017 (UTC)

,, Our goal in Wikipedia is to promote scientific knowledge and not to hide and deny the realities. I didn't deny and delete citations and realities about Kurdish origin theory, but I tried to add some citations about their Lurish origin theory. I apologize over the current edit warring. The next time I'll seek the challenges through it's logic path. Thank you Doug Weller for your kind recommendationsShadegan (talk) 08:57, 3 February 2017 (UTC)


 * I don't know anything about this dispute. Neither of you has been blocked on any Wikipedia. If someone translates the citations I can add the translation, which might help other editors if you go to DRN or have an RfC. Doug Weller  talk 12:01, 3 February 2017 (UTC)

{{ping|Doug Weller|} can we request a reliable user like who knows Persian to translate the sources? --–  Hossein Iran  « talk »  17:32, 3 February 2017 (UTC)


 * Once posted you can't fix a ping, you have to make a new, signed edit., do you want to comment/assist? Doug Weller  talk 18:13, 3 February 2017 (UTC)


 * I can't read the Perso-Arab script unfortunately. I can only read Persian written in the Latin alphabet. Btw, I have no idea what is going on here on this article, I just fixed the name of the article. --HistoryofIran (talk) 18:59, 3 February 2017 (UTC)
 * {{ping|Doug Weller|} then can i translate the Persian references now? --–  Hossein Iran  « talk »  21:42, 3 February 2017 (UTC)
 * Your ping is still not right, it's If someone translates them, giving them the same numbers they have on the article page, I can copy that over.  Doug Weller  talk 11:56, 4 February 2017 (UTC)

WP:DRN , Please have a look to non-Persian citations mentioned in the paper if you can't read Persian. I wonder what is the sensetivity about inserting some authentic resources that believed the Kalhor is of Lurish origin, except ethnocentric users who believe to sole pure identity of Kurdish for this tribe!! What they afraid of?! Is a theory so dangerous? By the way, even Kurdish historians has categorized Kalhor as a Lurish tribe. Best Regards Shadegan (talk) 14:03, 4 February 2017 (UTC)


 * I don't mean translate the sources, just the actual citations. G Translate gives:


 * And dispersion in Iran territory - H. Bhtvyy - 1377 - Tehran.

^ tribes, nomadic tribes of the country. Ali numbered. Publisher knowledge generation. Iran. 1368. ^ Ayatollah Mohammadi. Siri in political history. Publishing ask him. 1382 ^ land and people of Iran, Abdul Saeidian, life science publications, Tehran 1377 ^ history of the monarchy, Saeed Nafisi, Nashraqbal, Tehran 1317, Page 25 ^ NATIONAL LIFE ethnic genealogy. Ismail Yvrdshahyan.antsharat Farzan day. Tehran 1380, First Edition. Page 173 and 174 ^ geographical Iran. Mr. Abbas Jafari. Geographical Institute and geographical cartography. Tehran 1379 ^ Oskar von Niedermayer, Under the Scorching Sun: Iran war experiences of the German expedition to Persia and Afghanistan, Dachau, 1925; tr. Keykavus Jahandari, as Zir-e aftab-e suzan-e Iran, Tehran, 1984, pp. 75-76, 96-114. ^ Atsamalmlk, travel Mirza Khanlrkhan, edited by M. Mahmoudi, 1351 ^ Dvbd, Baron, travel Lorestan and Khuzestan, translation MH Arya, 1371 Saeidian, Abdul ^ Rawlinson, art, travel Rawlinson, passing through Khuzestan transportation, translation Alexander Amanullah, 1362


 * but that's not good enough to identify the sources. And
 * I, pp. 317-19
 * ^ Bedlisi, I, pp. 317-19
 * ^ Mirza Sami?a, tr., comm., p. 171


 * don't provide enough information to WP:VERIFY. I'm hoping one of you will go to DRN or start an RfC. I'm not getting involved in the actual content dispute. Doug Weller  talk 14:28, 4 February 2017 (UTC)



I raised the issue and went to DRN. I hope the dispute be solved peacefully.Shadegan (talk) 10:47, 5 February 2017 (UTC)
 * Comment One of you folks posted a request for a third opinion; and formally speaking, that process does not apply, as there are already more than two people involved, the matter had not been discussed thoroughly, and indeed there does not seem to be a very specific issue on which a third opinion is needed. I will say in passing, though, that citations need to be more detailed than a lot of those shown here, in order to meet WP:V. If a book is cited, it needs an author, title, year, publisher, and page number at the very least, and ideally should also have an isbn and information about where it was published: and if a translated volume is used, the translator, as well. Vanamonde (talk) 15:47, 8 February 2017 (UTC)

REFERENCES BOGUS AND MISTAKE DEDUCTION
Users were closed due to vandalism claims and claim your free copy of the new foundations. Drsfrnamh Myrzakhanlrkhan ol Etesam not nothing Drmvrdtbarklhrhagfth use of such sentence as the source is vandalism. even if it were doing winter Rftnddydh example of such words must also be said Shdhych communication to the public Klhrndasht on page Klhravrdh; this depends, Ghyrazklhrha relatives Dygrhmchvn Svranyhay dry colon, Goran, Zanganeh, Sanjabees, Lakas and ... there Vdarndvhych word of Klhrdrayn source Bsyarjyb it is not use. The next Drmvrdmnb log book Vkhvzstanh Ykbardygrjmlh handout Lorestan Lorestan, according to the tribes Azkrdhahm Drpshtkvh Vagrbamntq Shmabh look at the source of that offensive Lrhstnd all Kurds world! The source said the Kurds because Drpshtkvh Lorestan! However, according to the table on page 428 431 Vsfhh bottom of the page Vsfhh 238 and 239 of this book was made Rabaadahay Tnaqzsh see, of course, strange words in this book too, for example the bottom of page 429 says Bajlanhayy Radrsrplzhab Drhmvn saw that? I think leaving age of 4. Susan Zyraftab Drmvrdmnb books say that it was such a consul not even including Khvdnvysndh; Bsyarvjyb mistakes in the form of novels written in the logbook Zyadast including that on page 37 Mesopotamia was that people Azqdym Krdvtrk Vashur Arabic Rasrzmyny know! Yaaynkh Raazlrha Baḵtīārīs Drbyshtrsfhat this book apart !! knew that his sample BOOK page 50, page 28 Mediterranean Rakhlyj knows? Vaz·hmh Jybtraynkh Isfahan Rashhrbkhtyary Havmrkzbkhtyary Hadansth! Is one who can rely on this book! Which sciences are not seen in any itinerary resources Book have Haastnadshvd But the story of the next Drmvrdmnb Godan Kurds book is a collection of perceptions Khdmttvn say that this source is directed by Shmadydh; Shmaazkjantyjh take that Goran is the meaning of all the tribes of Kermanshah? The second part Vjyby source of irrelevant words as a phrase inaudible Azmvrgan assembled under German Vkhavrshnas said Svdkhvd Nrajht and Kurds making! When Morgan said, speaking residents of south Kurdistan name Darndvlky Knndyny Lak Lak South Kurdistan Hakrdtbarndvbashndgan Hstndtbq Khvdshmaavrdhay source, not the other way around words tell Lakas source Lrn rest Lrn Kurds because they speak Heads Heads !!!!! While linguists makers Kurdish Azgvyshhay Vdrmyan considered dialects of Kurdish Tbartbqh have, Windfuhr, G. (2009). The Iranian Languages, Routledge, p. 587  Rüdiger Schmitt: Die iranischen Sprachen in Gegenwart und Geschichte. Wiesbaden (Reichert) 2000.  Rüdiger Schmitt (Hg.): Compendium Linguarum Iranicarum. Wiesbaden (Reichert) 1989.  V. Minorsky, "Lak", Encyclopaedia of Islam.  Drmvrdmnb Ali Akbrvqay draft 13th century, which needs no further explanation enough Ykbarmnb Rabadqt Just Sing! Shmadrayn the one hand, the source said Yagfth Lrhabh Sanandaj is Rsdvaqa something is funny! However, the source of half Yabyshtrsnndjy Habaydlrbashnd Vdrnzrgrftn account! Of course, this talk that the Lrstanh Yalrstan in Kermanshah Kermanshah Nice Chyzjyby because throughout history Vtahmyn decades ago Lrzban cities such as Skinheads, Borujerd, Malayer, Tuyserkan and ... Part Azayalt center of Kermanshah is Kermanshah Kermanshah Andvdrbyshtrdvran Havhkvmt Haayn in Lrzban part Azayalt fifth Yaastan Kermanshah have been centered divisions in Iranian history, p. 5,  According to the source Zyadshvn old urban and rural population of the country before Vhmzmansh Radrnzrgrftn division. the country and the region is a migration migrate out according to different seasons Habdazan Bsyarbvdh, Sanyadlyl did not give a specific time every part Jz’lrstan Byvfth Dygrmaastnbat that people are Yashhr Lor. However Shmabaydgft logic that Western Azerbaijan have left Azerbaijan have been called Hstndchvn Tvastany! Turkey all Turkish people leave their name Hstndchvn !!!, great Vbhtrbgvym Third, the majority of people are Kalhor road Yabalatrazayn guy Vaqlyty this road are road Nhapayyntrazayn population, Rabadrnzdykyhay in Srplzhab Muslim garb, Krndghrb Vqsrshyryn and a large Rvstahavjmyt Azkrdhay Sunni Sourani Vahl right road Payyntrazayn are, in the meantime Where are you in Kalhori Yatbaranhaamdh source is the word ?! Khvdbdalhsyn Saeidian author's book, Il Klhrrayky most important part hordes Krdayran is known tribes. When Larry theory Tbarbaydbyaydkh weight of Kurdish descent resources Bashdnh Yanzdyk it was like 180 degrees even a source Larry Tbarbvdn Vjvdndashth Bashdvbrasas disorders Layqtvt.(پهلوون شهرگرگها (talk) 08:57, 7 March 2017 (UTC))