Talk:Kingyo Used Books

Review(s)
Dropping here:
 * ANN's Right Turn Only vol. 1 ANN vol. 2 ANN RTO vol. 3
 * CBB: vol. 1 vol. 2 vol. 3
 * Active anime vol. 1
 * CWR vol. 1 vol. 3
 * About.com vol. 1
 * Manga Life vol. 2
 * Mania.com vol. 2
 * Otaku USA: vol. 3


 * vol. 1 by Katherine Dacey (pass WP:SPS)
 * vol. 1 by Noah Berlatsky (pass WP:SPS)
 * vol. 1 by Melinda Beasi (pass WP:SPS)
 * About.com: Comic-Con 2010 Best/Worst Manga

Thank you very much; I have cited them in the page, and will add reference numbers to them soon. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Apollo-kun (talk • contribs) 18:18, 13 May 2010 (UTC)
 * No problem. Added 2 More reviews


 * Using ANN and CBB won't be difficult while using the Blog like reviews is trickier because you must put forward that the person who blogged the review is an expert in the Manga/Comics field. --KrebMarkt 14:46, 14 May 2010 (UTC)


 * Both Dacey and Beasi are former editors of PopCultureShock (WP:A&M/RS) so they should pass, as well as Berlatsky, writer for The Comics Journal. // I'm adding that Shaenon K. Garrity also reviewed it for Anime News Network. Gabriel Yuji (talk) 16:43, 1 December 2014 (UTC)