Talk:Kundiman

Kundiman vs. Philippine classical music
Philippine classical music isn't necessarily kundiman. Kundiman should remain separate from Philippine classical music. -- The SunKing  03:00, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

On the true origin of the Tagalog Kundiman
To Mr/Miss Ushiwaka,

I have edited the Kundiman article to correct some unsupported claims and allegations that you have posted with regards to the origin of the Kundiman as Kapampangan (or originating from the province of Pampangga). Could you cite any references or any historical documents written by reliable scholars and historians to support your claim that the Kundiman of the Tagalogs originated from the province of Pampangga?

I have done quite a major research about the Kundiman and nowehere did I find any reference written by scholars, musicologist and historians that the Tagalog Kundiman was "originally a Kapampangan war song" as you claimed it to be.

Please be more careful and responsible by doing a more rigid and serious research on Philippine Music before posting about the Kundiman in the Wikipedia. Many Filipino students depends on Wikipedia.

Please find time to read the following works and articles written by reliable writers, scholars and historians which points to the fact that the Kundiman is purely Tagalog in origin and not Kapampangan [Note: some articles are written in Spanish so please use any online "Language Tool" available over the net to translate them] :


 * Literature; A Historico-Critical Study" by Prof. Eufronio Melo Alip, Manila: U. S. T. Press, 1930. pp.17,65
 * Music and Theater of the Filipino People" by R.C. Banas, from El Filipino: Revista mensual Vol I No. 9 (1926)
 * Filipino Folk Song" by Percy Hill from the Philippine magazine. [Vol. XXIII, no. 3, p.147]Philippine Education Co. Manila, 1926. p.147
 * Indio Batangueno" by Wenceslao E. Retana, Manila, Tipo-Litografia de Chofre y Cia, 1888. p.25
 * Filipinos" by Don José Montero y Vidal, Madrid, Tip. del Asilo de Huérfanos del Sagrado Corazon de Jesús, 1883. p.106
 * Tagalian Merriness" by Karl Scherzer from "Circumnavigation of the Globe by the Austrian Frigate Novara in the Years 1857, 1858 & 1859."
 * de la conversación Familiar Español-Tagalog by V.M. de Avella,Manila, C. Miralles, 1874. p. 116

You might as well visit the National Library of the Philippines in Manila to read Dr. Francisco Santiago's 1931 work entitled  "The Development of Music in the Philippines" before posting anything about Philippine Music in the Wikipedia.

Maraming salamat po. Ian-James R. Andres Ian Andres (talk) —Preceding comment was added at 03:55, 24 February 2008 (UTC)

Pls ID
Could someone kindly identify the kundiman sung within the first eleven minutes of the American movie They Were Expendable. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 120.28.162.13 (talk) 10:37, 20 December 2018 (UTC)

what is tagalog of "this song was related
what is y 143.44.145.191 (talk) 03:17, 4 September 2023 (UTC)