Talk:Kylie Minogue/Archive 6

Tension critical acclaim
Tension is one of the highest ranking critically acclaimed pop albums of all time on Metacritic. This being omitted from the lead is confusing. PHShanghai &#124; they/them (talk) 07:38, 15 April 2024 (UTC)


 * Not really. Her critically acclaimed singles aren't mentioned either as well in the opening section. Hotwiki (talk) 07:57, 15 April 2024 (UTC)
 * Also, please stop changing "highest selling" to "best selling". There's nothing wrong with the term. Even artist Dua Lipa used the term "highest selling" when she presented an award to Kylie Minogue at the Brits Award 2024. This seems like another unnecessary change to the opening paragraph, that doesn't improve the article. Hotwiki (talk) 08:00, 15 April 2024 (UTC)
 * As for the infobox picture, I like the cropped version from . Just use that file from that editor. Hotwiki (talk) 08:05, 15 April 2024 (UTC)
 * "Critically acclaimed" singles are most usually never mentioned in the lede (see Ray of Light (song) in Madonna but an album having an 80+ score on Metacritic and winning a grammy is notable for the lead section. Why remove the mention of critics loving her album? It was her first grammy win in 20 years...
 * Additionally, the cropped 1 image is too close to her face. If someone can remove the Cantonese subtitles then we would have more space to work with, but we have to make the best of what we have. PHShanghai &#124; they/them (talk) 16:28, 15 April 2024 (UTC)
 * The cropped file by 750h+ was fine. Also may I remind you, not ALL Kylie Minogue albums have a Metacritic rating. Her first to sixth studio album don't have a Metacritic page. I'm sensing a pattern here, why do you keep the changing the lead section? Before, you mentioned her 4 PWL albums were teen pop albums. You claimed that Disco/Magic had "significant noise". Then you mentioned that the other Fever singles had the same chart success as Can't Get You Out of My Head. Now you didn't like the photo in the infobox, so you changed the picture for the second time. When someone cropped the image, you reverted it to your own upload. And now you keep insisting that Tension being critically acclaimed needs to be mentioned in the lead, and so as Padam Padam winning a Grammy in your most recent change. Hotwiki (talk) 17:05, 15 April 2024 (UTC)
 * "and the Grammy-winning "Padam Padam" from the album Tension (2023) respectively" that line is incredibly wordy. Especially compare to her other album campaigns, in which the lead single is the only one mentioned in the lead section: "She continued reinventing her image and experimenting with a range of genres on her subsequent albums, which spawned successful singles such as "Slow", "I Believe in You", "2 Hearts" and "All the Lovers"." Seehow that line didn't mention the parent album/year of those singles. Also "Come Into My world" also won a grammy and it isn't mentioned in the lead section. Hotwiki (talk) 17:23, 15 April 2024 (UTC)
 * Keep the lead section as it is. You are heavily emphasizing on the Tension era in the lead section, by mentioning that Padam Padam won a Grammy, mentioning that single came from the album Tension, mentioning Tension's year of release (2023) and highlighting that Tension is "critically acclaimed". The lead section should be brief. Hotwiki (talk) 17:39, 15 April 2024 (UTC)
 * A: This is literally admitting to WP:OWN behavior. Anyone can change the lead section on Wikipedia, point blank period. Where did I say that the critical acclaim was based on Metacritic alone? Albums can be acclaimed without Metacritic, see Madonna.
 * B: Grammy winning Padam Padam is wordy, but "In the following years, Minogue became the only female artist to have a number-one album and a top ten single, from the 1980s to the 2020s in the UK Charts" isn't wordy? You don't seem to care about wordiness when it is regarding something you insist on keeping in the lead...
 * C: What is wrong with the album year release date? That's MOS for all singer lead articles, see Katy Perry and Lady Gaga..... PHShanghai &#124; they/them (talk) 07:01, 26 April 2024 (UTC)
 * You only edit this article by changing the lead section again and again which is becoming a pattern. You've already proposed a lead section change from RFC, and most of the editors in this talk page have said, it was not improvement. I suggest you edit other articles, instead of drastically changing the lead section whenever you make an edit in this article. Hotwiki (talk) 07:35, 26 April 2024 (UTC)
 * If we look up at the history of this article, you've always find something to change in the lead article – which in my opinion, doesn't improve the article and you've been proven wrong by your previous claims in the past about Minogue's output. In the next few weeks or days or months, you would continue your pattern, by making another drastic change to the lead section, and like the previous times you've edited the article, I don't think it will benefit the article in any shape of form. Hotwiki (talk) 07:38, 26 April 2024 (UTC)
 * As for her Grammy wins, its already been pointed that she won two Grammy Awards in the lead section. No need to point out in the lead section when were those two times. You did that first with Padam Padam. And now you're mentioning her 1st Grammy win (Come into My World). We aren't enumerating all or any of her Brit Awards or Aria Awards wins in the lead section, for you to highlight her which song she got her 1st/2nd Grammy win. Hotwiki (talk) 07:45, 26 April 2024 (UTC)
 * Also no need link the Wikipedia article of Time magazine in the lead section, as there's also a link for the Wikipedia article for Time100, which contains the Wikipedia article link for Time (magazine). 1 Wikipedia link related to Time magazine is enough, especially this article isn't about Time. Hotwiki (talk) 08:00, 26 April 2024 (UTC)
 * As for you accusing me of WP:OWN, well me calling you out for your "editing pattern" in this article and reminding you about your false claims regarding Minogue's output doesn't mean I am owning this article. I just simply disagreed with your edits, hence why your edits were reverted. I've also explained to you several times in this talk page/edit summaries on why your edits were reverted. Hotwiki (talk) 08:09, 26 April 2024 (UTC)
 * Also to further comment on this drastic change by PHShanghai. There's no need to exclude Charlene Robinson as that was her breakthrough acting role. No need to remove the year (1993), she joined Deconstruction, especially the year when joined Parlophone and Bmg were mentioned. There's no need to mention the parent album of "Padam Padam". The lead section should be selective on which projects should be highlighted, hence why NOT every Kylie Minogue album is mentioned in the lead section. The first product released by BMG Rights Management for Kylie Minogue was "Dancing" not Golden the album."Dancing" was released in January 2018. Golden the album was released in April 2018. So once again,, thats another misinformation you've added in the lead section.Hotwiki (talk) 08:26, 26 April 2024 (UTC)