Talk:Lake Untersee/GA1

GA Review
The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.''

Reviewer: Deryck C. 22:17, 23 April 2011 (UTC)

At first glance, the article is mostly up to good article standard. There are a few minor things, mostly regarding content sourcing, which I need to see improved before the article can completely qualify for GA, and a few other stylistic things unrelated to GA criteria which would be good to to. --Deryck C. 22:17, 23 April 2011 (UTC)

Sourcing

 * Infobox
 * harvnb may be a better option for the "references" part.


 * Lead section
 * also known as Lake Unter-See An inline citation for this will be useful, possibly from a scientific catalog listing?
 * "one of the most unusual lakes on earth with a pH like strong Clorox" Source has the sentence in a different version. Double quotation marks should only be used for direct quotes.
 * The lake is dammed by the Anuchin Glacier feeding the lake and has no outlet. Water is lost through sublimation and ablation of the ice cover. It'd be useful to have a citation for this line as well.

Addressed all.♦ Dr. Blofeld  10:06, 24 April 2011 (UTC)
 * Expedition
 * Inline citation #9 can be moved to the end of the paragraph to cover more text.
 * Done.-- Nvvchar . 11:39, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

Not sure what you mean.♦ Dr. Blofeld  10:06, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

Wiki-links
Removed.♦ Dr. Blofeld  09:55, 24 April 2011 (UTC)
 * Infobox
 * Why Untersee Oasis? (Please forgive my ignorance in Antarctic natural history.)
 * Lead section
 * The Other uses template should probably point towards Untersee rather than the redirect page Untersee (disambiguation)
 * Otto-von-Gruber-Gebirge (Gruber Mountains) I personally think it's unnecessary to have the list the mountain range's name in two languages, especially given that there is an article on them. I'd suggest noting the German name of the mountain range in the Gruber Mountains article, and keep only one of the two names on this article.

Agreed. Removed German.♦ Dr. Blofeld  10:49, 24 April 2011 (UTC)


 * History
 * Austral summer seems to be a better link than Southern hemisphere

That links to summer. We don't have an article on austral summer. I think southern hemisphere is appropriate unless we have a specific article..♦ Dr. Blofeld  10:48, 24 April 2011 (UTC)
 * Okay. Not a great concern. --Deryck C. 12:53, 24 April 2011 (UTC)


 * Geography
 * (not related to GA criteria) the phrase "evaporation and ablation" sounds somewhat logically confusing, given that vaporisation is a subset of ablation. Ignore this comment if "evaporation and ablation" is actually technically accurate in this context.
 * I think its OK.♦ Dr. Blofeld  10:43, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

Done, I think...♦ Dr. Blofeld  10:48, 24 April 2011 (UTC)
 * Research studies
 * I'd suggest changing the 2nd "conductivity" link's text to "electrolytic conductivity", so distinguish it from "electrical conductivity" above.

I think its a pretty comprehensive article even if relatively short, given what information there is currently available on it online..♦ Dr. Blofeld  10:51, 24 April 2011 (UTC)
 * That's fine. This article is long enough. There are featured articles on chemical elements that are shorter than this article. --Deryck C. 12:53, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

Other things
The separation of History, Research studies and Expeditions seem rather arbitrary. Is there a better way of organising the content, possibly merging content and moving them around to give a Geography section and a subdivided History section which covers both the lake's discovery and the expeditions? (Not crucial, current structure of the article is largely clear and follows a rough chronological order)
 * Sectioning

Done.♦ Dr. Blofeld  09:52, 24 April 2011 (UTC) Changed to "given".♦ Dr. Blofeld  09:55, 24 April 2011 (UTC)
 * History
 * "mooted" carry strong legal and political connotations. Do you really mean it?
 * Research studies
 * The introduction of the shorthand H2S seems unnecessary to me, since that is the only place in the article where hydrogen sulphide is mentioned.

Written as word♦ Dr. Blofeld  09:48, 24 April 2011 (UTC)
 * Expeditions
 * The indented part of this section would be better off being an inline bulleted list. A bit more rewriting of the text may be necessary to completely avoid possible accusations of plagiarism from the cited source.

Altered.♦ Dr. Blofeld  09:48, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

Final things...
One, possibly two, things that need to be done and this will become GA!


 * The inline list suffers from a few grammatical mistakes and typos. Also because the "heading" for the bulleted list ends with a colon, each bullet point must contain a phrase that will complete the sentence ending in the colon, or a complete sentence on its own if it's impossible to complete the sentence ending with the colon.
 * Lake Untersee lies in the interior of the Gruber Mountains of central Queen Maud Land in East Antarctica, which is roughly on the same longitude as the northern coast of Namibia. It is situated 90 kilometres (56 mi) to the southwest of the Schirmacher Oasis. A citation for this will be useful, possibly from an Atlas, as there is a (remote) chance that this will be challenged as original research. Nevertheless, I don't think anyone will dare to challenge its factual accuracy so it's not GA-crucial. --Deryck C. 13:03, 24 April 2011 (UTC)


 * See my note below about Location relative to Schirmacher Oasis Philh-591 (talk) 19:55, 25 October 2023 (UTC)

I think that's sorted. OK?♦ Dr. Blofeld  13:41, 24 April 2011 (UTC)


 * In the last bullet point, do you mean "In situ" (and possibly italicised)? And is "provided" meant to be a verb or adjective in the 3rd bullet point? --Deryck C. 13:57, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

I've altered it but I wasn't happy with the bulleted list. It looked untidy. I think its fine in prose.♦ Dr. Blofeld  15:41, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

Promoted!
Well done. I have sometimes been picky beyond GA standard during the review, thanks for putting up with it! A few future improvements that editors of this article may consider:
 * 1) The map has a blue edge near the bottom. Plus, I don't think it's appropriate to use Mercator projection for anything on Antarctica anyway.
 * 2) There may be a better way to present the references using Harvard citation templates, especially for the ones that were cited repeatedly throughout the article. Deryck C. 21:08, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

Thankyou sir. I was thinking of also nominating Lake Burton, Antarctica. Needs a bit of copy editing I think.♦ Dr. Blofeld  22:04, 24 April 2011 (UTC)

Location relative to Schirmacher Oasis
Lake Untersee is to the south-east, of the Schirmacher Oasis, not the south-west. The given reference states the distance from the Schirmacher Oasis, but not the direction. Per the coordinates from the article pages

As can be seen, Lake Untersee has a greater eastern longitude than the Schirmacher Oasis, so it is to the southeast of the oasis.

Fortunately I noticed this on OpenStreetMap from the warmth of my temperate latitude habitation. Philh-591 (talk) 19:53, 25 October 2023 (UTC)