Talk:Leibniz Law

I think I might have created this article in vain, since there is a much more complete article on the identity of indiscernibles. It must be said of that article however that it is not the case that the identity of indiscernibles is called leibniz law, rather what is sometimes called leibniz law is the principle of indiscernibility of identicals and sometimes the conjunction of both. It is very important to distinguish between both principles, since the indentity of indiscernibles has been challenged, for instance by Max Black (I'll look up the reference), and defended by others such as Russell, (Inquiry into Meaning and Truth). Whereas the indiscernibility of identicals hasn't been challenged. So both principles do not have the same degree of plausibility and ought to be distinguished as they are in contemporary philosophy.--MoisesMB (talk) 04:50, 21 November 2008 (UTC)