Talk:Lilliput Troupe

I think that this article should be with "Dr. Mengele"

Link9er 15:48, 5 January 2006 (UTC)

Agreed. -bobsanders

I don't agree. Merging will strip them of a seperate identity that they currently hold outside of Mengel, their nemisis.Gareth E Kegg 00:57, 15 January 2006 (UTC)

No way. Keep them seperate. To do otherwise would be demeaning. "Lilliput Troupe" just needs expansion and better writing. -nappyfrau

This entry is horribly written. And and and... Anyway, if more can be written about the troupe, it deserves to remain an individual entry. However, it should only briefly explain Mengele's sadistic brutality. A link to Mengele can provide the rest of the context. -anglicizedhauser

Links are used for this purpose. I actually agree this article HAS to be kept separate. -Tagli_one

Yes, I agree to. This should not be joined with Mengele, it just needs some more work.

NO. Do not merge them. The family deserves to be seperated from Mengele. They deserve their own identity. This should definitely remain separate. Firstly, I never would have found it if it weren't a separate article, although possibly linked incorrectly (I found it off of the "troupe" article). Even though the article is mostly linked to Mengele, it's still a specific enough instance to cite as it's own, as well as the fact that it contains some information on them (albeit scarce) that is independent from their link to Mengele. In addition, I agree there is a certain concern with stripping them of a separate identity on here if it were to be merged. If any other article were ever to reference this as well, which is a possibility, they should be independently referential. - Grahamular