Talk:Limor Livnat

Killing of Livnat's nephew
I am not sure if the info about 'Benyo' belongs on this page at all. Even if it does, it seems rather one-sided (the reports I saw said he was already at the tomb, that the "police men" were not all actually police men, and that they shot at them as they were leaving. 128.8.209.30 (talk) 13:55, 27 April 2011 (UTC)


 * I changed the wording to reflect that the shooting took place *after* the visit to the tomb. Hence there should now be 100% consistency between the article, what you state above, and the IDF probe referenced in the Hareetz article.
 * Neither the current version of the Wikipedia article nor the Hareetz article mention anything about non-police participation in the shooting. I am not sure how important that is as long as it seems to be undisputed that it was a PA police officer that did the actual shooting. Could you maybe share a link to the "the reports I saw" so that the rest of us can evaluate to which degree this is an important piece of information that ought to be included. Morten Johnsen (talk) 04:25, 28 April 2011 (UTC)


 * As all (when, who, what, how) statements in the paragraph in question seems to be indisputable facts (no opinions), the only way I can understand that the paragraph could possibly be one-sided is that it is selective in which facts that is currently included. If that is the case, please contribute to solving this neutrality dispute by adding/suggesting additional factual statements that you feel would make the article more balanced. Morten Johnsen (talk) 01:53, 3 May 2011 (UTC)


 * In lack of any discussion/contributions I'm removing the "neutrality disputed" banner. Morten Johnsen (talk) 19:54, 6 May 2011 (UTC)