Talk:Line 1 (Shenzhen Metro)

Lacking infos
1. How long does the train run from Luohu to the Airport? 2. How long have to walk (metres and/or minutes) from the airport station to the check-in counters?

84.73.123.149 (talk) 00:24, 12 December 2011 (UTC)

Requested move 6 January 2018

 * The following is a closed discussion of a requested move. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a move review. No further edits should be made to this section. 

The result of the move request was: Moved. Per WP:IAR, I have decided to bypass the formal seven-day waiting period and go ahead with the move. There is already strong precedent to support it, such as the successful RM mentioned by the nominator (which was virtually identical to this one), Jc86035's RfC, and the NYC subway articles referred to by ToThAc. It probably could have been considered uncontroversial in the first place. Biblio (talk) 18:00, 7 January 2018 (UTC)

Same as Talk:Line_1_(Beijing_Subway). A metro system is not a place. feminist (talk) 13:56, 6 January 2018 (UTC)
 * Line 1, Shenzhen Metro → Line 1 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 2, Shenzhen Metro → Line 2 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 3, Shenzhen Metro → Line 3 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 4, Shenzhen Metro → Line 4 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 5, Shenzhen Metro → Line 5 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 6, Shenzhen Metro → Line 6 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 7, Shenzhen Metro → Line 7 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 8, Shenzhen Metro → Line 8 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 9, Shenzhen Metro → Line 9 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 10, Shenzhen Metro → Line 10 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 11, Shenzhen Metro → Line 11 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 12, Shenzhen Metro → Line 12 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 13, Shenzhen Metro → Line 13 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Line 20, Shenzhen Metro → Line 20 (Shenzhen Metro)
 * Chongming Line, Shanghai Metro → Chongming line
 * Line 1, Shanghai Metro → Line 1 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 2, Shanghai Metro → Line 2 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 3, Shanghai Metro → Line 3 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 4, Shanghai Metro → Line 4 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 5, Shanghai Metro → Line 5 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 6, Shanghai Metro → Line 6 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 7, Shanghai Metro → Line 7 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 8, Shanghai Metro → Line 8 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 9, Shanghai Metro → Line 9 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 10, Shanghai Metro → Line 10 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 11, Shanghai Metro → Line 11 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 12, Shanghai Metro → Line 12 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 13, Shanghai Metro → Line 13 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 14, Shanghai Metro → Line 14 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 15, Shanghai Metro → Line 15 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 16, Shanghai Metro → Line 16 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 16, Shanghai Metro (old) → Line 16 (defunct)
 * Line 17, Shanghai Metro → Line 17 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 17, Shanghai Metro (old) → Line 17 (defunct)
 * Line 18, Shanghai Metro → Line 18 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 19, Shanghai Metro → Line 19 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 20, Shanghai Metro → Line 20 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 21, Shanghai Metro → Line 21 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 22, Shanghai Metro → Line 22 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 23, Shanghai Metro → Line 23 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Line 24, Shanghai Metro → Line 24 (Shanghai Metro)
 * Pujiang Line, Shanghai Metro → Pujiang line
 * Line 1, Nanjing Metro → Line 1 (Nanjing Metro)
 * Line 2, Nanjing Metro → Line 2 (Nanjing Metro)
 * Line 3, Nanjing Metro → Line 3 (Nanjing Metro)
 * Line 4, Nanjing Metro → Line 4 (Nanjing Metro)
 * Line 10, Nanjing Metro → Line 10 (Nanjing Metro)
 * Line S1, Nanjing Metro → Line S1 (Nanjing Metro)
 * Line S3, Nanjing Metro → Line S3 (Nanjing Metro)
 * Line S8, Nanjing Metro → Line S8 (Nanjing Metro)
 * Line S9, Nanjing Metro → Line S9 (Nanjing Metro)


 * Comment: Is the current list (based on "Line 1", Line 2 ... presumably) exhaustive? I'm still a bit apprehensive, if commas create problems, how about naming them to "Shenzhen Metro Line 1", for example?  No News  !  14:31, 6 January 2018 (UTC)
 * There was an RfC about this, though only several editors participated because it's not the most interesting topic. It would be inconsistent with the articles which don't need disambiguators like Daxing line, and it would imply "Shanghai Metro" etc. to be part of the titles. Jc86035 (talk) 14:46, 6 January 2018 (UTC)
 * Not exhaustive. Other pages can be moved as well. feminist (talk) 16:42, 6 January 2018 (UTC)
 * Support, except the Chongming and Pujiang lines do not need their disambiguators. I would prefer "(abandoned proposal)" but "(defunct)" should probably be fine, and the articles might not need to exist (could be merged into an article on expansion of the metro or something?) if the proposals are abandoned. Jc86035 (talk) 14:46, 6 January 2018 (UTC)
 * Disambiguators removed. feminist (talk) 16:52, 6 January 2018 (UTC)
 * Support per nom. With regard to the defunct lines, I echo Jc86035's sentiment, I think maybe we don't need an article for each one, could maybe go into one article called List of cancelled Shanghai Metro lines or merged into an article about expansion/Shanghai Metro main article itself.  Heights (Want to talk?) 19:07, 6 January 2018 (UTC)
 * Speedy support per precedent set by the New York City subways (1 (New York City Subway service), for example), and the fact that the identifiers should probably be there anyways. ToThAc (talk) 21:30, 6 January 2018 (UTC)


 * The above discussion is preserved as an archive of a requested move. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on this talk page or in a move review. No further edits should be made to this section.