Talk:List of Bulgarian football transfers summer 2024

CSKA outgoing transfers
Can we please agree to leave the transfers for CSKA as they are now? If you wish to have them entirely removed, kindly outline why here. I did see your edit about them not being confirmed by the team. While I do not think they have to explicitly be confirmed by the team (we have a news article outlining that their contracts are expiring and they will be leaving), in order to not have an editing war, I simply commented them out for the time being. The idea of commenting them out is that, when we inevitably have an exact confirmation of which teams they're joining and/or that their contracts are up - we can simply put them back in with updated links/references and not have to go back and find/redo the coding part. --Yupyuphello (talk) 10:56, 8 June 2024 (UTC)


 * Валентин Йосков не е играч на ЦСКА 2 а на ЦСКА 1948- 2 и е освободен от там. 62.73.100.119 (talk) 06:27, 9 June 2024 (UTC)
 * Fixed, please type in English. --Yupyuphello (talk) 08:38, 9 June 2024 (UTC)

For example I don't think Kylian Mbappé was included in Real Madrid's Wikipedia page, even though there were news articles for months claiming he has already signed for the club? We all just need to wait until Monday to hear officially, which players have been released and newly signed. Going by your logic, we need to add all of the players that are going to be out of contract or released and just comment them in as we go along. ZloKBG (talk) 11:07, 8 June 2024 (UTC)


 * Weirdly enough, the ping function didn't work - keep that in mind if I respond slowly. My logic was aimed at making an exception in this specific case, as we both have opposing views, hence a compromise would be leaving it commented out for ease of update when we do get the official confirmation, in one way or another.
 * How do you think we should, going forward, handle news articles stating assuredly that somebody is joining or leaving a team? I agree in essence, that we need explicit confirmation, but I would also like to note that a lot of the Second League and a fair amount of the First League teams do not actively manage their websites and/or post explicit confirmation of incoming and outgoing transfers in an up-to-date manner. This in turn means that a lot of the transfers need to be sourced from secondary sources like Sport websites (which I actually prefer), which is what I've been doing so far. An alternative that comes to mind is, of course, interviews with the players themselves and/or social media or news articles highlighting players' postings regarding their own transfer.
 * Also, how do you think we should handle loan contracts - we generally know when they expire (30th June if I'm not mistaken), but I have noticed some players were listed as incoming transfers when there is no news confirming their return (and without refs). Do we simply cite the original news article that stated how long the loan would be for and go off that? --Yupyuphello (talk) 11:33, 8 June 2024 (UTC)
 * Please stick to secondary sources when possible - no point in switching to CSKA's website when we have a perfectly good secondary source. If you do want to switch it up to another source (whereever there is a good reason to do so) - please make sure to actually update the entire reference in the generic style I use, including a new archive link, since your change basically broke the reference by having it link to two separate main sources, one via the archival link. --Yupyuphello (talk) 17:25, 17 June 2024 (UTC)

lazar marin
Lazar Marin is a new player for Krumovgrad and not for Arda https://dsport.bg/krumovgrad-obavi-privlichaneto-na-opiten-branitel~166179.html#parent=section 62.73.100.119 (talk) 22:19, 9 June 2024 (UTC)


 * Fixed. --Yupyuphello (talk) 10:55, 10 June 2024 (UTC)

Ludogorets
Leaving a note here - regarding your recent changes to the Ludogorets part of the list. I have reverted your changes, as to my eye, they seem counterproductive, namely: 1. Elisey Sarov is part of the first team, per the team's official roster page in their website - that means he is eligible for those games even if he is used in their lower teams, hence this internal transfer should be noted, especially since he participated in friendlies and was called up to the team for their last game of the previous season. Whether the transfer is internal should not matter when there is a clear reflection in the roster - the three teams operate as interconnected but separate entities and we should have some citations for any changes to the roster, especially when these could influence the foreigner quotas. 2. Noting two separate transfers via notes in the Out section is simply wrong - Chouiar came back from a loan and was then loaned out again, there are two separate actions/transfers within the same transfer window.

I'm open to constructive feedback and talking this through, but please initiate changes after we've finished this discussion. --Yupyuphello (talk) 21:45, 12 July 2024 (UTC)