Talk:List of Royal Navy admirals (1707–current)

Raw links for people to add
The article titles for admirals there will be reasons to add,taken from other succession lists etc. — Preceding unsigned comment added by LE (talk • contribs) 05:41, 27 December 2018 (UTC) The SineBot created an edit conflict while I was preparing a massive addition I must now repeat from scratch,as I am not a cut-and-paster...I intended to sign once I had added substantive content that I had merely set the stage for. LE (talk) 05:57, 27 December 2018 (UTC)

Admirals of the Fleet
Commencing with Lord Torrington at the head of the list, all Admirals of the Fleet are listed except for the following. Did any of them hold the rank of admiral?

King Edward VII Kaiser Wilhelm II Tsar Nicholas II Prince Henry of Prussia all later Admirals of the Fleet aside from the Duke of Edinburgh (who never held the rank of admiral) are already listed Titles are not all given in article titles and order as Admirals of the Fleet does not always coincide with order in which they became Admiral. LE (talk) 06:21, 27 December 2018 (UTC)

First Naval Lords
If not encountered above...I am taking this back further than some other lists,but not all incumbents reached Admiral rank Unlike other categories these Admirals are generally shown in inverse order of incumbency. those listed here before are now on the main list

Commanders in Chief Home Fleet
If not encountered above... Francis Bridgeman (Royal Navy officer) Stanley Colville Lewis Bayly (Royal Navy officer) Henry Ruthven Moore Alban Curteis Frederick Dalrymple-Hamilton Angus Cunninghame Graham Edward Neville Syfret Michael Denny John Eccles (Royal Navy officer) William Davis (Royal Navy officer) Wilfrid Woods John Frewen

Vice-Admirals of the United Kingdom
If not encountered above... Michael Seymour (Royal Navy officer, born 1802) Sir Michael Culme-Seymour, 3rd Baronet Montague Browning Martin Dunbar-Nasmith John Edelsten Peter Reid (Royal Navy officer) Deric Holland-Martin Nigel Henderson John Bush (Royal Navy officer) William O'Brien (Royal Navy officer) Derek Empson Anthony Griffin (Royal Navy officer) Anthony Morton James Eberle

Commanders-in-Chief Portsmouth
If not encountered above... Henry Bruce (Royal Navy officer, born 1792) Sir Thomas Sabine Pasley, 2nd Baronet George Elliot (1813-1901) Edward Fanshawe (father of Arthur Dalrymple Fanshawe above) George Willes Archibald Lucius Douglas Day Bosanquet Assheton Curzon-Howe Arthur Moore (Royal Navy officer) Sydney Fremantle Arthur Waistell William Wordsworth Fisher William Milbourne James Charles Little (Royal Navy officer) Geoffrey Layton Guy Grantham Manley Laurence Power  Alexander Bingley Frank Hopkins (Royal Navy officer)

Commanders-in-Chief the Nore
If not encountered above... Charles Talbot (Royal Navy officer) Nathaniel Bowden-Smith William Kennedy (Royal Navy officer) Albert Hastings Markham Hugo Pearson  Charles Drury Sir Richard Poore, 4th Baronet Hugh Evan-Thomas William Goodenough Edwyn Alexander-Sinclair Hugh Tweedie Edward Evans, 1st Baron Mountevans Studholme Brownrigg Reginald Drax George Hamilton D'Oyly Lyon Harold Burrough Cecil Harcourt Cyril Douglas-Pennant Geoffrey Oliver Frederick Parham Robin Durnford-Slater LE (talk) 07:50, 27 December 2018 (UTC)

Commanders-in-Chief Naval Home Command
If not encountered above... Horace Law Andrew Lewis (Royal Navy officer) David Williams (Royal Navy officer) Richard Clayton (Royal Navy officer) Desmond Cassidi

Second Sea Lords
If not encountered above... Beauchamp Seymour, 1st Baron Alcester Anthony Hoskins Richard Vesey Hamilton Henry Fairfax (Royal Navy officer) Frederick Bedford George Egerton (Royal Navy officer) Frederick Hamilton (Royal Navy officer) Herbert Heath Hubert Brand Michael Hodges Cyril Fuller William Whitworth Alexander Madden Guy Russell Sir St John Tyrwhitt, 2nd Baronet Royston Wright Frank Twiss Gordon Tait (Royal Navy officer) Simon Cassels Desmond Dreyer

LE (talk) 20:10, 27 December 2018 (UTC)
 * Louis Keppel Hamilton was a son of a 2SL by a daughter of Henry Keppel above whose son was Colin Richard Keppel (Admiral on Retired list 1917)

Commanders-in-Chief Plymouth/Devonport
If not encountered above...as ever I am arbitrarily starting at some point after Richard Darton Thomas

Lord Charles Montagu Douglas Scott Lewis Beaumont  Wilmot Fawkes  Alexander Bethell  Cecil Thursby Richard PhillimoreRudolph Bentinck  Eric Fullerton Ralph Leatham Henry Pridham-Wippell Robert Burnett Maurice Mansergh Charles Pizey Richard Onslow (Royal Navy officer) LE (talk) 15:59, 27 December 2018 (UTC)
 * Arthur Farquhar William Houston Stewart son of Houston Stewart above Augustus Phillimore William Dowell (Royal Navy officer)  Edmund Fremantle

Controllers of the Navy
If not encountered above... Charles de Bartolome Reginald Henderson Frederic Wake-Walker Ralph Edwards (Royal Navy officer) Lindsay Bryson Kenneth Eaton LE (talk) 16:42, 27 December 2018 (UTC)

Far East Fleet
If not encountered above... Clement Moody Denis Boyd Patrick Brind Alan Scott-Moncrieff Gerald Gladstone David Luce

South Atlantic
If not encountered above... Desmond McCarthy Herbert Annesley Packer Articles disagree on whether they actually reached four-star rank or when

To categorize
Arthur Murray Farquhar Edmund Poe Henry Frederick Stephenson Astley Cooper Key Sir Francis Sullivan, 6th Baronet Charles Hillyar Frederick Montresor (apparently Retired list) Gresham Nicholson Arthur Phillip Thomas Griffin (Royal Navy officer) Charles Frederick (Royal Navy officer) Campbell Tait LE (talk) 22:22, 27 December 2018 (UTC)

Upcoming
Tony Radakin Timothy Fraser

LE (talk) 08:27, 27 December 2018 (UTC)

Times Obituaries Admirals from another site
per http://www.pdavis.nl/Obits.php the following unencountered-above (some from before times I copied names from lists used above and/or on those lists as ranks below Admiral) persons died as Admirals RN and had obituaries in The Times:


 * Reginald Friend Hannam Henderson 1846-1932 uncle of Reginald Henderson above and brother of William Hannam Henderson 1845-1931 both also Admirals

LE (talk) 20:49, 27 December 2018 (UTC)

Admirals reported at yet another site to hold the rank in 1914 and not encountered above
This site has a list of those who held the rank in 1914.

The Vice- and Rear-Admirals listed there might use a career check for later promotion.

LE (talk) 06:25, 28 December 2018 (UTC)

Early admirals from yet another site
I am omitting persons mentioned at http://www.napoleon-series.org/military/organization/Britain/Navy/c_flagranks.html who became Admirals of the Fleet as those are already listed at the AotF article...

LE (talk) 00:00, 29 December 2018 (UTC)

Other resources...working on...

 * I've been searching DNB (people dead by 1900) for word "admiral".


 * the page http://www.dreadnoughtproject.org/tfs/index.php/Royal_Navy_Flag_Officers_of_the_Great_War has LOTS of candidates...anyone whose "final rank" is Admiral(retired or not) or AotF.

LE (talk) 06:39, 2 January 2019 (UTC)
 * I am a little uncomfortable extending the time frame before the Queen Anne era because it seems that back then the distinction between ranks and postings was loose.

Royal Naval Biography
This book's text is searchable online at https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Royal_Naval_Biography but it has issues. It's supposedly a snapshot of the Navy List at a certain point listing people by rank held at that time but it was published in sections between 1823 and 1835 with the result that it (and every survivor of those promoted to vice admiral of the red in 1825 had become a full admiral by 1830).
 * calls Sir Henry Nicholls (KCB 1820) as "senior vice admiral of the red" (person next in line to become full admiral) in his bio
 * has post-captains by date of rank out to 1831 even though Sir Henry's name led the list of full admirals promoted in 1825

I am going to list their entries as ordered by rank here, bolding any who are on the list in the article, deleting any verified as not reaching the rank of Admiral. I will not create links at least to start with (Sir Henry Nicholls KCB aforesaid has no article and features on neither the Henry Nicholls nor Henry Nichols disambiguation pages).

I will note gazetted promotions to persons listed by rank and date:
 * ADM=Admiral (of the Blue or higher)
 * VAR= Vice admiral of the Red
 * VAW= Vice admiral of the White
 * VAB= Vice admiral of the Blue
 * RAR/RAW/RAB for the respective Rear admirals...

once a rank below Admiral is confirmed as the highest a person reached the entry can be deleted though it would still be useful for the List of Royal Navy vice admirals or List of Royal Navy rear admirals (on neither of which I am planning to work as the lists would be longer & more difficult than this one).


 * King William IV ADM 1799
 * 1st Earl of St. Vincent ADM 1795
 * Sir George Montagu ADM 1801
 * Viscount Keith ADM 1802
 * John Henry ADM 1804
 * Isaac Prescott ADM 1805
 * Thomas Spry ADM 1805
 * Sir Charles Morice Pole ADM 1805
 * Charles Nugent ADM 1808
 * Charles Hamilton ADM 1808
 * John Holloway ADM 1809
 * George Wilson ADM 1809
 * Charles Henry Knowles ADM 1810
 * Thomas Pakenham ADM 1810
 * James Hawkins-Whitshed ADM 1810
 * Arthur Kempe ADM 1810
 * James Douglas ADM 1810
 * Henry Savage ADM 1810
 * Sir Richard Hussey Bickerton ADM 1810
 * George Bowen ADM 1810
 * Robert Montagu ADM 1810
 * Edward Tyrell Smith ADM 1812
 * Thomas MacNamara Russell ADM 1812
 * Sir Henry Trollope ADM 1812
 * John Wickey ADM 1813
 * John Fish ADM 1813
 * John Knight ADM 1813
 * Edward Thornbrough ADM 1813
 * Sampson Edwards ADM 1814
 * Lord Saumarez ADM 1814
 * Thomas Drury ADM 1814
 * Albemarle Bertie ADM 1814
 * William Carnegie Earl of Northesk ADM 1814
 * James Vashon ADM 1814
 * Edward Pellew Viscount Exmouth ADM 1814
 * Isaac Coffin ADM 1814
 * John Aylmer ADM 1814 ("senior admiral of the blue" as of publication)
 * The entire sets of 1819 and 1821 Admirals are on the list and omitted to save space
 * Sir Henry Nicholls ADM 1825
 * Sir Herbert Sawyer ADM 1825
 * Sir Davidge Gould ADM 1825
 * Sir Richard Goodwin Keats ADM 1825
 * Robert Devereux Fancourt ADM 1825
 * Honourable Sir Robert Stopford ADM 1825
 * Mark Robinson ADM 1825
 * Thomas Revell Shivers ADM 1825
 * John Dilkes ADM 1825
 * Sir Thomas Foley ADM 1825
 * Sir Charles Tyler ADM 1825
 * Sir Manley Dixon ADM 1825
 * George Losack ADM 1825
 * Sir Thomas Bertie ADM 1825
 * Isaac George Manley ADM 1830
 * Edmund Crawley ADM 1830 these two jumped directly to Admiral of the White
 * Thomas Williams ADM 1830
 * Thomas Boulden Thompson (VAR 1821) died 1828 as vice admiral
 * William Hargood ADM 1830
 * John Ferrier ADM 1830
 * Charles Stirling Died 1833 having been barred from promotion past vice admiral of the white after a court-martial
 * Richard Incledon-Bury died 1825 as vice admiral...will delete
 * Sir Robert Moorsom ADM 1830
 * Charles Hamilton ADM 1830
 * Honourable Henry Curzon ADM 1830
 * Sir Lawrence William Halsted ADM 1830
 * Sir Harry Burrard-Neale ADM 1830
 * Joseph Sydney Yorke ADM 1830
 * Honourable Arthur Kaye Legge ADM 1830
 * George Stewart, 8th Earl of Galloway ADM 1830
 * Sir Francis Laforey ADM 1830
 * Sir Philip Charles Henderson Durham ADM 1830 stated in his article to have been promoted in December after others of 1830
 * Sir Israel Pellew ADM 1830
 * Alexander Fraser (VAR 1825) died a Vice Admiral December 29th 1829...will delete
 * Benjamin Hallowell Carew ADM 1830
 * Lord Amelius Beauclerk ADM 1830
 * William Taylor ADM 1830
 * Sir James Nicoll Morris (VAR 1825) died April 1830 before promotions of that July
 * Thomas Byam Martin ADM 1830
 * John Lawford ADM 1830
 * Frank Sotheron ADM 1830
 * Thomas Wolley will probated October 1826 as a Vice Admiral
 * Sir William Johnstone Hope (VAR 1830) died 1831
 * Lord Henry Paulet (VAR 1830) died 1832
 * Charles William Paterson ADM 1837
 * Sir George Cockburn ADM 1837 these two jumped directly to Admiral of the White
 * James Carpenter ADM 1837
 * Robert Barton (VAR 1830) died 1831
 * Sir Graham Moore ADM 1837
 * Matthew Henry Scott (VAR 1830) died 1836, will probated as a Vice Admiral
 * Joseph Hanwell ADM 1837
 * Sir Henry Bayntun ADM 1837
 * Sir Richard King (VAR 1830) died a Vice Admiral 1834
 * Sir Edward Griffith Colpoys (VAR 1830) died 1832
 * Sir Edward Foote (VAR 1830) died 1833
 * Sir Richard Lee ADM 1837
 * Peter Halkett ADM 1837
 * William Bedford (Royal Navy officer)(VAW 1825) died 1827
 * Philip Stephens ADM 1837
 * Honourable Charles Elphinstone Fleeming ADM 1837
 * Charles Vinicombe Penrose (VAW 1825) died 1830
 * William Hotham ADM 1837
 * Sir Pulteney Malcolm ADM 1837
 * Sir John Gore (VAR 1830) last person ranked as vice admiral by the book...via addenda & 1825 promotion...died 1836
 * William Nowell(VAB 1825) died 1828
 * James Bissett died Rear Admiral in 1824
 * John Clements (VAB 1825) died July 1825
 * Sir John Harvey ADM 1837
 * Sir Henry Hotham (VAR 1830) died 1833
 * Sir Josias Rowley ADM 1837
 * Edward Codrington ADM 1837
 * Sir George Parker ADM 1837
 * Robert Plampin (VAW 1830) died 1834
 * Sir Henry Blackwood (VAW 1830) died 1832
 * John Erskine Douglas ADM 1838
 * George Byng, 6th Viscount Torrington (VAW 1830) died 1831
 * Sir Ross Donnelly ADM 1838
 * Sir John Beresford ADM 1838
 * Thomas Eyles (VAW 1830) died 1835
 * Thomas LeMarchant Gosselin ADM 1841
 * Sir Charles Rowley ADM 1841
 * Samuel James Ballard (VAB 1825) died 1829
 * Robert Rolles (VAR 1837) died 1839...will proved January 1840...National Archives calls him VAW
 * Walter Locke (VAW 1830) died 1835
 * David Milne ADM 1841
 * James Young (Royal Navy officer, born 1762) (VAW 1830) died 1833
 * James Macnamara (RAR 1825) died 1826
 * Sir Robert Waller Otway ADM 1841
 * William Lukin (VAW 1830 as William Windham) died 1833
 * in this position later gazettes before 1837 have a Shuldham Peard (a "superannuated rear admiral" to RNB...died a vice admiral 1832 per DNB) and 1837 a Richard Dacres (Royal Navy officer) who died in January 1837
 * Edward Fellowes (VAR 1837) died a Vice Admiral 1841
 * Sir Willoughby Thomas Lake ADM 1841
 * Charles Ogle ADM 1841
 * Henry Raper ADM 1841
 * Sir William Charles Fahie (VAB 1830) died 1833
 * Sir George Eyre (VAR 1837) died 1839
 * Robert Lambert (Royal Navy officer) (VAB 1830) died 1836
 * Joseph Bingham (Royal Navy officer) (RAR 1825) died December 1825
 * Robert Dudley Oliver ADM 1841
 * D'Arcy Preston ADM 1841 inserted 1840
 * Man Dobson ADM 1841 (superannuated in 1819 per RNB) appears in this position in the 1830/1837/1841 Gazettes
 * Thomas Boys (VAB 1830) died Nov 1832
 * John Clarke Searle will proved as rear admiral 1825
 * Sir Charles Brisbane (RAR 1825) died 1829
 * Sir John Talbot ADM 1841
 * John Richard Delap Halliday (VAR 1837 as John Richard Delap Tollemache) died July 1837
 * John Giffard ADM 1841
 * John West ADM 1841
 * Joseph Bullen ADM 1841 inserted here 1840
 * Stephen Poyntz ADM 1841
 * John, Lord Colville ADM 1841
 * John Cochet ADM 1841
 * Sir Archibald Collingwood Dickson (RAR 1825) died 1827
 * Robert Winthrop (1764-1832) (VAB 1830)
 * Sir Henry Digby ADM 1841
 * Sir Charles Ekins ADM 1841
 * Benjamin William Page ADM 1841
 * Honourable Philip Wodehouse (VAW 1837) died 1838
 * Thomas Alexander ADM 1841
 * Andrew Smith (RAR 1830) per Gentleman's Magazine died "senior Rear-Admiral of the Red" October 1831 
 * Sir Edward Berry (RAR 1830) died 1831
 * William Prowse (RAW 1825) died 1826
 * Lord Mark Robert Kerr (VAW 1837) died 1840
 * Sir James Athol Wood (RAW 1825)died 1829
 * Sir Thomas Harvey (Royal Navy officer)(VAW 1837) died 1841
 * Sir Richard Hussey Moubray (VAR 1841 as Richard Hussey Hussey) died 1842
 * Henry Richard Glynn ADM 1846
 * John Bligh (Royal Navy officer) (RAR 1830) died 1831
 * Sir Edward Hamilton ADM 1846
 * Sir Thomas Baker (VAR 1841) died 1845
 * Henry Evans (superannuated rear-admiral of 1821 & died 1842) and Sir Courtenay Boyle (retired captain in RNB & died 1844) inserted here as VAR 1841
 * Samuel Sutton (RAR 1830) died 1832
 * Sir Robert Laurie ADM 1846
 * William Hall Gage ADM 1846
 * John Maitland (Royal Navy officer) (RAR 1830) died 1836
 * Stair Douglas (RAW 1825) died 1826
 * William Cuming died 1824 as rear admiral
 * James Walker (Royal Navy officer) (RAR 1830) died 1831
 * Sir Charles Paget (VAW 1837) died 1839
 * Robert Williams (RAW 1825) died 1827
 * Richard Worsley (VAW 1837) last person ranked as Rear Admiral by the book...died January 1838
 * Aiskew Paffard Hollis (VAR 1841) senior non-retired post-captain at the time of the book...per DNB died vice-admiral 1844
 * Sir Henry Heathcote ADM 1846
 * Andrew Fitzherbert Evans (RAB 1825) died 1826
 * Sir Edward William Campbell Rich Owen ADM 1846
 * George James Shirley retired but then re-inserted as VAR 1841...died 1845
 * Richard Runwa Bowyer died in 1823 per RNB itself
 * George Frederick Ryves (RAB 1825) died 1826
 * Sir George Scott (VAR 1841) died December 1841
 * Sir Thomas Dundas (VAW 1838) died 1841
 * George Fowke (RAR 1830)died 1832
 * James Keith Shephard retired but re-inserted as VAR 1841...died 1843
 * Richard Harrison Pearson (VAB 1837) died 1838
 * Samuel Peter Forster on retired half-pay on 1838 Navy List...will proved 1840 as Rear Admiral
 * George Astle (RAB 1825) died 1830
 * Sir John Tremayne Rodd (VAW 1838) died October 1838
 * John Baker Hay died in 1823 per RNB itself
 * Sir Thomas Masterman Hardy (VAB 1837) died 1839 as vice admiral
 * William Cumberland (RAW 1830) died 1832
 * Graham Eden Hamond ADM 1847
 * Robert Honyman ADM 1847
 * Bartholomew James died 1827 or 1828
 * Sir Robert Lewis Fitzgerald retired but returned as VAR 1841...died 1844
 * Charles Pierrepont Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Josiah Nisbet died 1830...had been on retired pay by 1828
 * Volant Vashon Ballard (RAW 1830) died 1832
 * Hugh Downman ADM 1847 promoted by death of Gould 24th April
 * Thomas Bladen Capel ADM 1847
 * William Hanwell (RAB 1825) died as rear admiral 1830
 * Thomas Manby (RAW 1830) died 1834
 * James O'Brien, 3rd Marquess of Thomond ADM 1847
 * Richard Matson ADM 1847
 * Richard Raggett (RAB 1825) died 1829
 * John MacKellar ADM 1847
 * James Oughton died 1832...superannuated as rear admiral 1825
 * George Barker ADM 1847 had been superannuated in 1825 (later on retired half-pay)
 * Charles Adam ADM 1848
 * John Stiles(RAW 1830) died December 1830
 * Michael Halliday died July 1829 "the senior captain in the Royal Navy" per Gentleman's Magazine
 * William Granger(VAR 1846) died Jan 1848
 * Sir John Chambers White (VAW 1841) died 1845
 * Charles Campbell Not on 1827 Navy List
 * George White died 1835 as retired rear admiral
 * Adam Mackenzie died 1823 per RNB itself
 * Francis Vesey Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Henry Garrett (VAW 1841) had been on retired half-pay on 1830-1838 Navy Lists...died 1846
 * Walter Bathurst died 1827
 * Sir Adam Drummond ADM 1848
 * Robert Hall (VAW 1841) will proved 1842
 * Robert Lloyd (VAW 1841) died 1846
 * John Chesshyre (VAW 1841) had been on retired half-pay on 1830-1838 Navy Lists...reinstated 1840...died 1843
 * Sir Thomas Livingston ADM 1848
 * Lucius Hardyman (RAW 1830) died 1834
 * Christopher Laroche died 1850...had been court-martialed 1807 and kept on half-pay from 1830 thereafter
 * Joshua Sydney Horton (RAW 1830) died 1835 (will proved 1836) as rear admiral
 * Henry Bazely Not on 1828 Navy List
 * Sir Edward Brace (VAW 1841) died 1843
 * Sir Jahleel Brenton (VAW 1841) died 1844
 * Robert Mends died 1823 per RNB itself
 * Francis William Austen ADM 1848
 * Bendall Robert Littlehales (VAW 1841) had been on retired half-pay on 1830-1838 Navy Lists...reinstated 1840....died 1847
 * Robert Philpot Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Sir Patrick Campbell (VAB 1838) died 1841
 * Norborne Thompson (VAW 1841) died 1844
 * Sir Michael Seymour, 1st Baronet Not on 1830 Navy List but restored as RAB 1832 and died July 1834
 * Edward Stirling Dickson (VAW 1841) died 1844
 * Edward Rotheram died 1830
 * Charles Grant Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Thomas James Maling (VAW 1846) died 1849 as the senior VAR
 * John Acworth Ommanney ADM 1849
 * Henry Stuart (RAR 1837) died 1840
 * Zachary Mudge ADM 1849
 * George Wolfe died 1826
 * Henry Hill (VAR 1847) died 1849
 * John Mason Lewis died 1835 as a superannuated rear admiral of 1832
 * Charles Wollaston (VAB 1841) died 1845...had been on retired half-pay and reinstated
 * Alexander Wilmot Schomberg ADM 1849
 * Edward Durnford King ADM 1849
 * William Waller not on 1829 Navy List
 * Henry Vansittart (VAB 1841) died 1843
 * George Mundy ADM 1849
 * George Sayer (Royal Navy officer) (RAB 1830) died 1831
 * Robert Mansel died a rear admiral Jan 1838
 * Charles Tinling (RAR 1840 on reinstatement) died November 1840
 * Sir Philip Broke (RAR 1837) died 1841
 * Sir Frederick Lewis Maitland (RAR 1837) died 1839
 * James Brisbane not on 1828 Navy List
 * John Ferris Devonshire not on 1834 Navy List...on retired half-pay on 1830 Navy List
 * Frederick Warren (VAW 1846) died 1848
 * Richard Peacocke (VAB 1841) died 1846..had been on half-pay and reinstated
 * James Carthew ADM 1850
 * Sir Thomas Briggs ADM 1850
 * John Broughton (RAW 1837) died October 1837
 * 1837 Gazette inserts Thomas Cochrane, 10th Earl of Dundonald
 * George Heneage Lawrence Dundas not on 1835 Navy List
 * Nicholas Tomlinson (VAW 1846) died 1847...had been on half-pay and reinstated
 * William Parker ADM 1851
 * Tristram Robert Ricketts (VAB 1841) died 1842
 * George McKinley ADM 1851
 * James Katon (VAB 1841) rear admiral on retired half pay on 1834 Navy List but later reinstated...died 1845
 * Sir Charles Dashwood (Royal Navy officer) (VAB 1841) VAW on 1847 Navy List...died September 1847
 * Richard Curry (VAR 1848) ADM on reserved half pay list 1851
 * Sir William Hoste, 1st Baronet died 1828
 * Lenox Thompson not on 1836 Navy List
 * Charles Feilding not on 1839 Navy List
 * Thomas George Shortland Not on 1828 Navy List
 * William Skipsey (RAR 1841) died 1846
 * Marcus Samuel Hill Not on 1835 Navy List
 * Frederick Paul Irby (RAR 1841) died 1844
 * Sir Christopher Cole not on 1836 Navy List
 * George Ralph Collier Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Daniel Woodriff on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * John Wentworth Loring ADM 1851
 * John Winne died 1838 as retired rear admiral
 * Sir Robert Howe Bromley ADM 1851
 * Duncombe Pleydell-Bouverie (VAW 1847) died VAR in November 1850
 * Richard Goddard Not on 1834 Navy List
 * Richard Poulden (RAR 1841) died 1845 as rear admiral
 * Charles Otter Not on 1831 Navy List
 * Thomas Hurd Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Richard Pellowe Not on 1831 Navy List
 * John Dick ADM 1852
 * Peter Riboleau (VAW 1847) died in 1847
 * John Nash Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Stephen Rains Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Thomas Hand Not on 1829 Navy List
 * Farmery Predam Epworth Not on 1828 Navy List
 * Matthew Buckle (VAR 1849) died 1855...possibly Admiral 1852 on retired list? on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * John Allen (VAB 1846) VAR on 1850 Navy List on retired half-pay on 1839 navy list
 * James Noble (VAB 1846) died VAR in 1851 on retired half-pay on 1839 navy list
 * Sir Samuel Warren died RAW in 1839
 * Anselm James Griffiths (RAR 1841) died 1842
 * George Burdett Not on 1832 Navy List
 * James Nash Not on 1827 Navy List
 * Peter Spicer Not on 1830 Navy List
 * James Seward Not on 1829 Navy List
 * John Taylor Michell Not on 1834 Navy List
 * Thomas Philip Durell not on 1836 Navy List
 * Alexander Becher Not on 1827 Navy List
 * John Hatley Not on 1832 Navy List
 * Francis Holmes Coffin (RAR 1841) died 1842 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Jeffery Raigersfeld (RAR 1841) had been on retired half-pay on 1838 Navy List...reinstated 1840...died 1844
 * Charles Ryder Not on 1832 Navy List
 * Christopher John Williams Nesham ADM 1852 had been on retired half-pay on 1838 Navy List...reinstated 1840
 * Charles Bullen ADM 1852
 * John Wight ADM 1852
 * Henry Folkes Edgell (RAR 1841) died 1846 had been on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Cornelius Quinton not on 1840 Navy list
 * James Dunbar not on 1840 Navy List
 * William Butterfield (RAR 1841) died 1842 had been on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Richard Byron (Royal Navy officer) died rear-admiral in 1837
 * William Young (Royal Navy officer, born 1761) died VAB 1847 had been on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * George Tobin not on 1840 Navy List
 * James Sanders Not on 1835 Navy List
 * William Henry Webley Parry died rear admiral 1835
 * Edward Galwey (RAR 1841) died 1844
 * Richard Jones Not on 1829 Navy List
 * Richard Hawkins Not on 1828 Navy List
 * Thomas Cowan not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Henry Daniel not on 1840 Navy List
 * Jacob Walton (RAR 1841) not on 1846 Navy List on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy list
 * David Colby not on 1836 Navy List
 * Augustus Brine not on 1840 Navy List on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy list
 * James Coutts Crawford not on 1828 Navy List
 * John Hayes died 1838
 * Samuel Campbell Rowley (RAR 1841) died 1846 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Bulkley Mackworth Praed (VAR 1850) died October 1852 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy list
 * Samuel Mottley (RAW 1840 on reinstatement) died 1841 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Edward Walpole Brown (RAR 1841) died 1846 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * John Rouett Smollett (RAR 1841) died 1842 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * William Ricketts not on 1840 Navy List on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Alexander Skene not on 1829 Navy List
 * William LePoer Trench (RAR 1841) died 1846 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Edward Sneyd Clay (RAR 1841) died 1846 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Thomas Richbell not on 1834 Navy List
 * Benjamin Carter not on 1834 Navy List
 * Charles Inglis not on 1834 Navy List
 * Charles Carter (VAB 1846) died 1847 had been on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Thomas Browne (VAR 1850) died 1851
 * Edward O'Bryen not on 1830 Navy List
 * Francis Godolphin Bond not on 1841 Navy List on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Stephen Folvil not on 1834 Navy List
 * Archibald Dickson not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Henry Brown Tremlett ADM 1852 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy list
 * Sir Samuel Pym ADM 1852
 * George Argles not on 1832 Navy List
 * Samuel Butcher (VAW 1848) died 1849 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Robert Jackson (VAB 1847) died as VAR June 1852
 * Sir Robert Barrie (RAW 1838) died 1841
 * Charles Bayne Hodgson Ross (VAB 1847) VAW on Dec 1848 Navy List...died that month
 * William Rathborne not on 1831 Navy List
 * Henry Matson not on 1830 Navy List
 * Sir Charles Malcolm (VAB 1847) VAW on 1850 Navy List...died 1851
 * John Serrell not on 1830 Navy List
 * Peter Heywood not on 1831 Navy List
 * Murray Maxwell not on 1831 Navy List
 * Charles Marsh Schomberg not on 1836 Navy List
 * Francis William Fane died rear admiral in 1844
 * Peter Hunt not on 1830 Navy List
 * George Elliot ADM 1853
 * William d'Urban died 1837
 * James Hillyar died 1843
 * Lord William FitzRoy ADM 1853
 * Lord George Stuart (Royal Navy officer) died rear-admiral in 1841
 * James Lind not on 1829 Navy List
 * Joseph Nourse not on 1829 Navy List
 * Robert O'Brien not on 1840 Navy List
 * Keith Maxwell not on 1829 Navy List
 * Matthew Godwin (VAB 1847) died 1849 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Hugh Pigot ADM 1853
 * James Master not on 1841 Navy List on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Salusbury Pryce Humphreys (RAW 1841 as Sir Salusbury Davenport) died 1845
 * John Tower died 1837
 * Kenneth Mackenzie not on 1828 Navy List
 * Edward Hawker ADM 1853
 * Alexander Campbell not on 1828 Navy List
 * Sir Charles Richardson (VAB 1847) died VAW November 1850
 * George Aldham not on 1834 Navy List
 * Francis Temple ADM on Reserved Half-Pay list Jan 21st 1854
 * Richard Budd Vincent not on 1832 Navy List
 * Arthur Farquhar (RAW 1841) died 1843
 * Henry Gordon ADM on Reserved Half-pay List Jan 21st 1854
 * Sir William Bolton not on 1832 Navy List
 * James Alexander Gordon ADM 1854
 * Frederick 6th Baron Aylmer ADM 1854
 * Richard Darton Thomas ADM 1854
 * John Quilliam not on 1832 Navy List
 * John Pilfold not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Hennah not on 1834 Navy List
 * William Pryce Cumby died 1837
 * George Digby not on 1832 Navy List
 * James Richard Dacres (1788-1853) (VAR 1852)
 * Peter Rainier not on 1836 Navy List
 * Henry Duncan not on 1836 Navy List
 * Henry Vaughan not on 1836 Navy List
 * Joseph Lamb Popham not on 1836 Navy List
 * John Surman Carden ADM 1855
 * John Sykes ADM 1855
 * James Watson not on 1836 Navy List
 * Charles Jones not on 1836 Navy List
 * John Hancock died 1839
 * John Wentworth Holland (RAB 1840 on reinstatement) died 1841 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * John Yelland not on 1836 Navy List
 * Woodley Losack not on 1840 Navy List
 * John Impey (VAB 1848) ADM on Reserved Half-pay List 1855
 * Alexander Robert Kerr not on 1836 Navy List
 * Donald M'Leod not on 1836 Navy List
 * Henry Manaton Ommanney ADM on Reserved Half-pay List 1855
 * Archibald Duff (RAW 1841) ADM on Reserved Half-pay List 1855
 * Hon. Donald Hugh Mackay died vice admiral in 1850
 * Sir Francis Mason (VAB 1849) VAR on 1852 Navy List...will proved as VAW 1853
 * Hon. Major Jacob Henniker (RAW 1841) died 1843 on retired half-pay on 1839 Navy List
 * Matthew Forster not on 1836 Navy List
 * Philip Carteret Silvester not on 1836 Navy List
 * James Johnstone not on 1836 Navy List
 * Thomas Staines not on 1836 Navy List
 * Thomas Brown ADM 1855
 * Alexander Shippard died 1841
 * Pownoll Bastard Pellew not on 1836 Navy List
 * John Bowen not on 1836 Navy List
 * Henry Laroche Not on 1836 Navy List
 * Robert Henderson (RAW 1841) died 1843
 * Lucius Curtis ADM 1855
 * John Louis ADM 1855
 * Edward Rodney died 1828
 * Bryan Hodgson (VAB 1849) died VAR Feb 1855
 * Hood Hanway Christian (RAR 1847) died 1849
 * Archibald Cochrane not on 1836 Navy List
 * Josiah Coghill Coghill (VAB 1849) died 1850
 * Nathaniel Day Cochrane (RAB 1841) died 1844
 * Sir James Alexander Gordon ADM 1854 is re-inserted here
 * John Ayscough ADM 1855
 * Thomas John Cochrane ADM 1856
 * William Hugh Dobbie not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Furlong Wise (RAB 1841) died 1844
 * Edmund Boger (RAB 1841) died December 1844
 * William Jones Lye (RAB 1841) died 1844
 * George Francis Seymour ADM 1857
 * Hon. George Poulett (VAR 1854) died 1854
 * Hugh Cook not on 1836 Navy List
 * James Haldane Tait (RAB 1841) died 1845
 * Gilbert Heathcote not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Beauchamp-Proctor (VAB 1850) ADM retired
 * Charles James Johnston (VAR 1854) died 1856 or 1857
 * Edward Ratsey (VAB 1850) ADM retired 1857
 * Edward Hawkins not on 1839 Navy List
 * Richard Turner Hancock (RAB 1841) died 1846
 * James Murray Northey not on 1836 Navy List
 * Charles Philip Butler Bateman (VAB 1851) not on 1853 Navy List
 * Mauritius Adolphus Newton DeStarck (RAW 1846) died 1848
 * William Cook not on 1836 Navy List
 * Arthur Lysaght (VAB 1851) retired?...died 1859?
 * Hon. Josceline Percy (VAW 1852) VAR on 1855 Navy List..died 1856 or 1857
 * Anthony Maitland Earl of Lauderdale ADM 1857
 * Granville Proby ADM 1857
 * Granville Waldegrave, 2nd Baron Radstock (VAR 1855) died 1857
 * George Cadogan, 3rd Earl Cadogan ADM 1857
 * Sir Edward Tucker ADM 1857
 * John Edgcumbe not on 1839 Navy List
 * John Oakes Hardy not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Maude (RAB 1841) died 1843
 * Samuel Hood Inglefield (RAB 1841) RAW on 1847 Navy List...died 1848
 * Edmund Palmer not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Augustus Montagu (RAB 1841) alive as active RAR mid-1851...not on 1853 Navy List
 * John Bastard not on 1836 Navy List
 * Valentine Collard (RAB 1841) died 1846
 * John Fyffe died 1835
 * Sir Edward Chetham ADM 1857
 * George Cocks not on 1839 Navy List
 * Reuben Caillaud Mangin (RAB 1841) died 1846
 * William Croft (RAB 1841) RAR on 1849 Navy List...not active by 1852 Navy List ADM 1857 on reserved list per 1860 Navy List
 * John Phillimore not on 1840 Navy List
 * Francis Beauman (RAB 1841) died 1846
 * James Robert Phelps (RAB 1841) 1844-1850 Navy Lists shows James Robert PHILIPS here as RAB & RAR...not on 1853 Navy List
 * William King not on 1836 Navy List
 * Pringle Stoddart (RAB 1841) RAW on 1847 Navy List...died 1848
 * Andrew King not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Bowles ADM 1857
 * Hyde Parker (Royal Navy officer, born 1784) (VAB 1852) died 1854
 * Charles Sibthorp John Hawtayne (VAB 1852) VAR on 1856 Navy List
 * James Whitley Deans Dundas ADM 1857
 * Samuel Jackson (RAB 1841) died January 1845
 * Sir Edward Thomas Troubridge RAR on 1849 Navy List... died as RAR 1852
 * Charles Gordon (RAB 1841) RAR on 1850 Navy List ADM on Reserved Half-Pay List 1858
 * George Harris not on 1836 Navy List
 * Thomas Garth not on 1841 Navy List
 * John Clavell not on 1846 Navy List
 * William Standway Parkinson not on 1840 Navy List
 * James Murray Gordon (RAB 1846) RAW on 1848 Navy List...died 1850
 * George Langford not on 1836 Navy List
 * Sir William Henry Dillon (VAB 1852) VAW on 1855 Navy List
 * James Bradshaw not on 1836 Navy List
 * Matthew Smith not on 1846 Navy List
 * Thomas Searle (RAB 1846) RAW on 1848 Navy List..died that December
 * Henry Hope ADM 1858
 * Sir Thomas Ussher (RAB 1846) died January 1848
 * Rowland Bevan not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Ward (RAB 1846) RAW on 1849 Navy List...not on 1853 Navy List
 * Samuel John Brooke Pechell (RAB 1846) died as RAW November 1849
 * Robert Cathcart not on 1836 Navy List
 * Robert Elliot (RAR 1850) died blind in 1854
 * Cuthbert Featherstone Daly (RAB 1846) RAW on 1848 Navy List
 * Philip Pipon not on 1836 Navy List
 * George Pigot not on 1836 Navy List
 * Edward Woollcombe not on 1836 Navy List
 * Fleetwood Broughton Reynolds Pellew ADM 1858
 * John Halsted not on 1836 Navy List
 * George Charles Mackenzie not on 1836 Navy List
 * Edward Pelham Brenton not on 1839 Navy List
 * Sir Francis Augustus Collier (RAW 1848) died 1849
 * George Miller Bligh not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Wilbraham not on 1836 Navy List
 * Charles Gill not on 1844 Navy List
 * James Wilkes Maurice retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Charles Dilkes not on 1846 Navy List
 * James William King (RAB 1846) died 1848
 * James Prevost retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Francis Newcombe not on 1841 Navy List
 * John Joyce not on 1840 Navy List
 * James Caulfield not on 1839 Navy List
 * William Godfrey not on 1836 Navy List
 * Joseph Spear not on 1839 Navy List
 * William Wells not on 1836 Navy List
 * Thomas Withers not on 1844 Navy List
 * Charles Napier ADM 1858
 * John Richard not on 1836 Navy List
 * George Sanders not on 1836 Navy List
 * James Townshend not on 1844 Navy List
 * Thomas Thrush not on 1841 Navy List
 * William Mounsey not on 1836 Navy List
 * Thomas Forrest not on 1846 Navy List
 * Richard Harward not on 1846 Navy List
 * George Bell not on 1839 Navy List
 * William Goate not on 1846 Navy List
 * Joseph James not on 1839 Navy List
 * John Davie not on 1836 Navy List
 * Henry Hume Spence not on 1844 Navy List
 * John Brett Purvis (VAB 1853) died 1857
 * George Andrews not on 1840 Navy List
 * William Buchanan not on 1836 Navy List
 * Edmund Joshua Moriarty not on 1836 Navy List
 * Edward Seymour Daily not on 1841 Navy List
 * George Cadman not on 1836 Navy List
 * Charles Bartholomew not on 1839 Navy List
 * William Henry Shirreff (RAB 1846) died 1847
 * John Simpson not on 1848 Navy List
 * Edward Dix not on 1839 Navy List
 * Henry Whitmarsh Pearse not on 1836 Navy List
 * Edward Kittoe not on 1836 Navy List
 * Richard Arthur (RAB 1846) RAW on 1848 Navy List...died vice admiral in 1854
 * George Paris Monke not on 1836 Navy List
 * Phipps Hornby ADM 1858
 * William Gordon (RAB 1846) on list as active RAR mid-1851
 * Francis Stanfell not on 1836 Navy List
 * Samuel George Pechell not on 1845 Navy List
 * Charles John Austen (RAB 1846) on list as active RAW mid-1851...not on 1853 Navy List
 * Spelman Swaine died 1848
 * Sir Francis Beaufort retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Benjamin Walker not on 1839 Navy List
 * John Maxwell not on 1836 Navy List
 * Philip Browne (RAB 1846) RAW on 1849 Navy List...not on 1852 Navy List
 * Matthew Barton Bradby not on 1836 Navy List
 * William Paterson not on 1839 Navy List
 * Henry Prescott ADM 1860
 * Thomas White died 1846
 * Thomas Graves not on 1836 Navy List
 * Nisbet Josiah Willoughby died rear-admiral in 1849
 * Edward Wallis Hoare (RAB 1847) RAW on 1849 Navy List...on reserved half-pay on 1853 Navy List ADM on reserved list 1860
 * William Elliot not on 1839 Navy List
 * James Collins not on 1836 Navy List
 * John Crispo not on 1845 Navy List
 * Robert Keen not on 1836 Navy List
 * John Lawson not on 1836 Navy List
 * Christopher Watson not on 1836 Navy List
 * Thomas White not on 1836 Navy List
 * George Sayer not on 1848 Navy List
 * James Andrew Worth not on 1845 Navy List
 * James Slade not on 1848 Navy List
 * William Williams Foote not on 1845 Navy List
 * Thomas Innes not on 1836 Navy List
 * Richard James Lawrence O'Connor not on 1836 Navy List
 * Francis Douglas not on 1845 Navy List
 * John Hudson not on 1836 Navy List
 * Robert Brown Tom not on 1836 Navy List
 * James Lillicrap retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848 Navy List
 * Walter Grossett died 1847
 * Francis John Nott not on 1840 Navy List
 * Lewis Shepheard not on 1839 Navy List
 * John Thompson ADM 1860 on Retired List
 * Robert Evans not on 1836 Navy List
 * Thomas Folliott Baugh retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-1853 Navy Lists
 * John Lamborn not on 1839 Navy List
 * John Baker not on 1848 Navy List
 * Alexander Innes not on 1840 Navy List
 * Charles Montague Fabian not on 1839 Navy List
 * Samuel Martin Colquitt died 1847
 * Gustavus Stupart retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848 Navy List...died 1850
 * John Willoughby Marshall not on 1836 Navy List
 * Anthony Abdy not on 1839 Navy List
 * Henry Evelyn Pitfield Sturt surname Grindall added on 1836 Navy List...not on 1840 Navy List
 * Richard Gaire Janvrin not on 1836 Navy List
 * George William Blamey not on 1836 Navy List
 * Sir John Coode (VAB 1854) pensioned 1855 and died 1858
 * Thomas Burton not on 1848 Navy List
 * Jeremiah Coghlan not on 1848 Navy List
 * Thomas Francis Charles Mainwaring retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * William Henry Byam not on 1840 Navy List
 * Robert Clephane not on 1840 Navy List
 * Joseph Packwood not on 1840 Navy List
 * Ralph Neville not on 1840 Navy List
 * William Flint not on 1840 Navy List
 * John Williams not on 1840 Navy List
 * Thomas Fellowes (RAB 1847) RAW on 1849 Navy List
 * Pitt Burnaby Greene not on 1840 Navy List
 * William Waldegrave retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848 Navy List
 * Thomas Huskisson not on 1848 Navy List
 * Henry Edward a'Court (RAB 1847) surname Repington added on 1848 Navy List...RAW on 1849 Navy List...on reserved half-pay 1853 Navy list
 * Thomas Coe not on 1840 Navy List
 * Bentinck Cavendish Doyle not on 1848 Navy List
 * John Pasco (RAB 1847) RAR on 1853 Navy List
 * John Hollinworth retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Clement Sneyd retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Richard Buck not on 1840 Navy List
 * Edward Scobell not on 1840 Navy List
 * John Duff Markland died 1848
 * William Fisher (RAB 1847) RAW on 1849 Navy List...not on 1853 Navy List
 * Abel Ferris retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Edward Harvey ADM 1860
 * Robert Merrick Fowler retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * William Fitzwilliam Owen (VAB 1854) pensioned 1855 and died 1857
 * Manley Hall Dixon ADM 1860
 * William Brooking Dolling not on 1848 Navy List
 * John Richards Lapenotiere not on 1848 Navy List
 * Alexander Jones (RAB 1848) not on 1853 Navy List 1860 ADM on reserved list
 * Benjamin Clement not on 1840 Navy List
 * Henry Dawson surname Damer added on 1840 Navy List
 * Donald Campbell retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Henry Hart retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Corbet James d'Auvergne not on 1840 Navy List
 * George Henderson retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Thomas Tudor Tucker died rear admiral on retired list in 1852
 * John Bowker not on 1848 Navy List
 * Henry Bourchier retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848 Navy List
 * John Strutt Peyton not on 1840 Navy List
 * Gardiner Henry Guion not on 1840 Navy List
 * Robert Worgan George Festing retired rear admiral of 1846 on 1848-53 Navy Lists
 * Peter John Douglas (VAB 1855) died 1858
 * Gawen William Hamilton not on 1840 Navy List
 * Edward Stopford not on 1840 Navy List

So far I have copied the post-captains down through 1811. The RABs of 1846 became post-captains in 1808-10. 1804 captains were VAB eligible by 1847.

I'll omit the "superannuated rear admirals" and "retired captains" but more to come.

I will be cross-checking with A Dictionary of Naval Biography (1849 but alphabetical) as well as Gazettes & Navy Lists and Haydn's Book of Dignities. I need to seek out later promotions to see who made it to Admiral and note that the listed captains include admirals at least as late as William Fanshawe Martin (died 1895) with Alexander Milne (died 1896) among the Commanders. LE (talk) 04:05, 6 January 2019 (UTC)

Since an 1838 Navy List was on Google Books, I checked everyone Vice-Admiral or above and the retired rear-admirals and captains on half-pay against the RNB roster.LE (talk) 01:36, 11 January 2019 (UTC)

1851 Gazette Snapshot
At mid-1851 the Gazette made reference to a Plan of Naval Retirement resulting in the pensioning off to the reserved half-pay-list of the following Admirals:
 * Frederick Watkins
 * Giffard
 * Glynn
 * Heathcote
 * Downman
 * Mackellar

The Active List of Admirals was:

Fleet
 * Thomas Byam Martin
 * Cockburn

Red
 * Gosselin
 * Ogle
 * Talbot
 * West
 * Charles Ekins
 * W H Gage
 * Hamond

White
 * Capel
 * Lord Thomond
 * Adam
 * Livingstone
 * Austen
 * J A Ommanney
 * Mudge

Blue
 * E D King
 * G Mundy
 * Carthew
 * Thomas Briggs
 * Dundonald
 * William Parker Bt GCB
 * George McKinley

page 1769 continues down through Rear Admirals of the White, junior admirals can be checked for promotion.LE (talk) 04:07, 7 January 2019 (UTC)

Retirees of 1939
The following currently unlisted admirals are on the Retired list of the 1939 Navy List with promotion dates indicated. Some were retired before reaching the rank of full admirals and others after. Some have articles and others do not.


 * Charles William Keighly-Peach DSO Feb 1928
 * George Bowes Hutton immediately precedes Bentinck
 * Ronald Arthur Hopwood CB between Bentinck and Corbett
 * Henry Blackett Feb 1929
 * Henry William Grant CB
 * Sir Charles Martin de Bartolome KCMG CB
 * Sydney Stewart Hall CB
 * Douglas Lionel Dent CB CMG
 * Sir Herbert William Richards KCB 3 days before Watson
 * Sir Cyril Thomas Moulden Fuller KCB CMG DSO same day as and immediately after Heard
 * Sir Arthur Kipling Waistell KCB 8 days after Fuller
 * Walter Maurice Ellerton CB same day as J.D. Kelly
 * Sir Percy Molyneux Rawson Royds KBE CB CMG July 1932
 * Louis Charles Stirling Woollcombe CB MVO
 * Henry Ralph Crooke CB
 * Alexander Victor Campbell CB DSO MVO same day as Earl of Cork
 * Sir Frank Larken KCB CMG same day as and immediately after Townsend
 * William Rawdon Napier CB CMG DSO30th September 1933
 * Humphrey Wykeham Bowring CB DSO
 * Sir Rudolph Miles Burmester KBE CB CMG
 * Henry Wise Parker CB CMG same day as Norris

Wherever no promotion date is given the last previously given promotion date applies. LE (talk) 00:53, 21 February 2019 (UTC)

1945 Navy List candidates to check for promotion
The practice of promoting by strict order of seniority dates at least to 1718 and from looking at Navy Lists during WW II it was still observed then with the sole exception of not every admiral getting to be an Admiral of the Fleet. The order in which men became Admirals was invariably that in which they had become Vice-Admirals, Rear-Admirals, and Captains. So just like the RNB list above that basically recapitulates 1820s Navy Lists, here are the flag officers in the last Archive.org Navy List (July 1945) who come after those listed here as admirals postwar including some known to have made it... bold means already listed...


 * Sir Henry Bernard Rawlings (Has an article as Bernard but promotion date to Admiral unclear)
 * Sir Robert Lindsay Burnett Admiral but rank date needed
 * Louis Keppel Hamilton
 * Irvine Glennie
 * Arthur Palliser
 * Sir Geoffrey John Audley Miles
 * Sir Frederick George Hew Hamilton-Dalrymple
 * Denis Boyd
 * Harold Thomas Coulthard Walker
 * Sir Clement Moody Admiral but rank date needed
 * Rhoderick McGrigor
 * Philip Vian
 * Charles Eric Morgan
 * William Tennant (Royal Navy officer)
 * Victor Crutchley
 * John Edelsten
 * Eric James Patrick Brind became Admiral
 * Oliver Bevir retired as vice admiral
 * Douglas Blake Fisher retired in 1948 and then ADM on retired list 1949
 * Cecil Halliday Jepson Harcourt promoted Admiral 1949
 * Wilfrid Patterson
 * Llewellyn Vaughan Morgan retired 1949 and then ADM on retired list 1950
 * Claud Barrington Barry ADM upon 1950 retirement
 * Sir Charles Saumarez Daniel ADM but rank date unclear
 * John Maurice Mansfield died a vice admiral
 * Thomas Hope Troubridge died on active duty as a vice admiral
 * James William Rivett-Carnac did not become an Admiral
 * John William Ashley Waller retired as vice admiral 1947
 * Reginald Henry Portal ADM 1950
 * Sir Ernest Russell Archer ADM on 1950 retirement
 * John Anthony Vere Morse did not become an Admiral
 * Harold Kinahan
 * Arthur George Talbot retired as Vice Admiral as did the not-to-be-confused Sir Arthur Allison Fitzroy Talbot
 * Gresham Nicholson
 * George Creasy
 * Henry Jack Egerton never full Admiral
 * William Edward Parry
 * Richard Shelley
 * Charles Henry Lawrence Woodhouse ADM rank date unclear
 * Henry Cecil Bovell
 * Leslie Haliburton Ashmore did not become an Admiral
 * John George Lawrence Dundas
 * John Walker Durnford
 * Honourable Sir Cyril Eustace Douglas-Pennant ADM rank date unclear was survived by his father
 * Edward Desmond Bewley McCarthy
 * Benjamin Charles Stanley Martin
 * Gervase Boswell Middleton promoted Admiral on retired list in 1952
 * Harold Hickling did not become an Admiral
 * Angus Cunninghame-Graham
 * Reginald Maxwell Servaes
 * Herbert Annesley Packer
 * Robert Don Oliver did not become an Admiral

They may have articles by some variant of their names if not linked here. Some made Admiral and some did not... LE (talk) 16:36, 12 January 2019 (UTC)

Introduction
Hi There is no mention of the promotional structure of Admirals prior to 1864 in regards to Admirals of the Colour and which rank superseded which for example an Admiral of the white was only outranked by Admiral of the Fleet until 1805 there after he was outranked by an Admiral of the red and the Admiral of the Fleet. I also think the notes section for all admirals prior to 1864 should mention their final rank colour where possible there is a starter list here: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Royal Naval Biography.--Navops47 (talk) 07:45, 1 February 2019 (UTC)
 * Apologies I just noted that some of the former recommendations have been added in the notes field I created separate pages for all admirals of colour I will link those where they are mentioned in the list.--Navops47 (talk) 08:16, 1 February 2019 (UTC)
 * I wouldn't mind the final ranks being mentioned though this was basically a function of how long one survived after reaching the level of Admiral. RNB however only mentions those who were were of particular colors when that book was compiled.LE (talk) 03:58, 2 February 2019 (UTC)
 * That's true but Sir William Laird Clowes seven volume book series 'The Royal Navy, A History from the Earliest Times to 1900' mentions Admirals of Colour throughout also Issac Schomberg's five volume book series lists admirals of colour by naval station prior to 1802. John Charnock's 6 volume book series from 1660 lists Admiral of Colour I have all of these books which are used as sources in modern books I have.--Navops47 (talk) 06:29, 2 February 2019 (UTC)
 * In the color days anyone who was an Admiral started out Blue, with rare exceptions; those who lasted long enough became White, and some of those lasted long enough to become Red. It would take a lot of checking to sort them out.LE (talk) 23:08, 4 February 2019 (UTC)

Early Admirals
I also note that the list currently starts at 1708 the articles Admiral of the North, Admiral of the South, Admiral of the North and West, and Admiral of the West all appointed admirals albeit English Navy between 1294–1412 and also Admiral of the Narrow Seas has admirals dating from 1552. other pages with Admirals in command Downs Station, Western Squadron, Commander-in-Chief, English Channel, Leeward Islands Station, Lisbon Station, there is a Template:Royal Navy fleets listing commands and stations.--Navops47 (talk) 08:07, 1 February 2019 (UTC)
 * 1708 is on par with the List of British Army full generals and frankly is about as far back as we can go while admiral was clearly a rank and not a job. Even starting where we do there is the issue of Stafford Fairborne whose name brings up no results searching the gazette and who basically vanished from the ranks after losing his place as functioning head of the navy. He survived until 1742 but other men passed up the list to Admiral of the Fleet even though it was supposed to be reserved for the senior admiral: it was basically a command from which he had been relieved, not a rank, at that time. To have a vague responsibility for defending certain ports or coasts is not the same as being at a certain high level of a professional hierarchy.LE (talk) 04:06, 2 February 2019 (UTC)
 * Hello I have three books on British naval history by Nicholas A. M. Rodger covering the years 660 to 1964. In 'The Safeguard of the Sea: a Naval History of Britain, Volume 1, 660–1649 (1997)' Appendix V Admirals and Officials pp.504-510 he lists all English Admirals officially appointed from 1295 to 1408 his source the Patent roll's. In Chapter 10 'Captains and Admirals 1204 to 1455. 'Admirals were appointed to command areas on a geographical basis into fleets or admiralties' 'They were responsible for assembling fleets for particular operations', 'organizing naval expeditions to Scotland and Ireland, Britanny, Gascony and Flanders., 'naval recruitment and naval administration', 'superintending the 'Sea Guard' Coastal militia for all coastal districts of England' and 'administering admiralty courts' and as these Admirals were clearly paid for their roles. In the same book 'Appendix IV Rates of Pay' mentions payment and pay scales as early as 1172 a job is by definition a paid position as modern admirals are. So I wouldn't call these vague responsibilities. All of Rodgers books chart the development Royal Navy under the headings Administration, Operations, Ships, Social History and Officers so we have a cohesive narrative which is important to provide readers with this information. If your going to set this list only from 1708 for the reasons you have stated please explain this in the lead section and provide sources that clearly state there was no form of organised structure nor were Admirals responsibilities the same prior to 1708 than they were after 1708.--Navops47 (talk) 06:14, 2 February 2019 (UTC)
 * As a practical matter the Act of Union 1707 makes a logical dividing line between the Royal Navy of Great Britain and of the former constituents. Gradual evolutions still covered substantial changes as what qualifies for logical coverage emerged from what doesn't. There is again a difference between having a responsibility/job and having a rank. If one was paid when and because one was C-in-C Penzance it's not the same as having an entrenched pay rate for an earned rank held irrespective of one's assignment. Would Baron Talbot of Malahide rate as an admiral by your reckoning?LE (talk) 07:53, 2 February 2019 (UTC)
 * I will repeat if your going to set the list only from 1708 for the reasons you have stated please explain the cut off reason for this for readers in the lead section and provide your sources that support your viewpoint thank you.--Navops47 (talk) 09:00, 2 February 2019 (UTC)

Dating needs changing
According to official and scholarly sources the birth of the modern British navy became the Royal Navy in 1660 following the restoration of the Monarchy. Here, supporting this date from this book and a single navy supporting this date here it was Charles II who named the English fleet the "Royal Navy," and it needs to be in line with the History of the Royal Navy who's open sentence is 'The official history of the Royal Navy began with the formal establishment of the Royal Navy as the national naval force of the Kingdom of England in 1660, following the Restoration of King Charles II to the throne'. If not you need to explain this omission otherwise readers might assume there was no commissioned officers of the Royal Navy holding the rank of Admiral prior to 1707 that are listed in this book this would also sort out your overlap issues of appointments thank you.--Navops47 (talk) 15:36, 5 February 2019 (UTC)
 * Additionally this would put it in line with this list from 1689.--Navops47 (talk) 16:11, 5 February 2019 (UTC)
 * Sticking with 1707/1708 avoids a period of truly chaotic appointments (vice- and rear-admiralships were also treated as postings rather than ranks) as well as the term as Lord High Admiral of Prince George of Denmark. Best to stick with the post-Union RN with however much explanation of that is necessary.LE (talk) 20:01, 7 February 2019 (UTC)
 * Hello please do your research correctly according to the British National Archives tell us the rank not an administrative posting they were introduced in the 17th century not 18th century and I know for a fact command flags for vice-admirals and rear-admirals were introduced in the (17th century) this is supported by the the Royal Navy National Museum that states 'The ranks of Admiral, Vice Admiral, and Rear Admiral arose directly out of the organisation of the fleet in 1620 into three parts' source here therefore your dating is incorrect if you leave as is it will be changed.--Navops47 (talk) 17:27, 8 February 2019 (UTC)
 * I came across a quote referring to the situation in 1699 where someone could move from serving as vice-admiral to rear-admiral if someone senior to him showed up.I have no interest in covering pre-Union-promoted admirals in this article...neither does Takvaal...start another one for them if you like. LE (talk) 17:47, 8 February 2019 (UTC)
 * May a respectfully remind you of Ownership of content and we also don't need multiple lists of Royal Navy Admirals e.g. (List of Royal Navy Admirals before the Act of Union in 1707 covering the years (1620 to 1706) based on commissioning rank criteria or List of Royal Navy Admirals (1660-1706) based on the actual naming date that makes no sense. It is consistent to be in line with both the lists of Admiral of the Fleet (1688-1995) and I am trying to avoid an Edit conflict with you over your dating criteria so we need to find a compromise it makes sense that possibly a List of Naval Royal admirals (1500-1660) would then be the logical dating progression to compliment it.--Navops47 (talk) 18:36, 8 February 2019 (UTC)
 * The quality of the article requires that earlier admirals be excluded. Going back even one First Naval Lord or one Admiral of the Fleet from the current beginning would bring in ambiguities where what we are trying to present as consistent ranks were treated as offices by tenure that could be given up. I have put a lot of effort into compiling something I regard as worthwhile...I will regard all that effort as wasted if those earlier admirals are not excluded.LE (talk) 01:44, 10 February 2019 (UTC)

Problem with display?
I just added Colin Richard Keppel and am not displaying the 52 years before him all of a sudden even though the edit history does not reflect a loss of data?LE (talk) 22:55, 16 February 2019 (UTC)
 * Another revision still has the 1865-1917 admirals before Keppel invisible?LE (talk) 01:36, 17 February 2019 (UTC)

Page Move
I have moved this page under a new title as the previous title List of Royal Navy admirals without a date descriptor it simply redundant and is misleading to readers as this article is completely at odds with these articles Royal Navy and History of the Royal Navy which are littered with references to Admirals. The arbitrary setting of political date has nothing to do with officers receiving a royal commission to the rank of admiral. Contrary to previous discussions it is evident that a kings commission to the rank of Admiral have been granted from as early as the 14th century to serving naval officers and only issued to sea commanders after 1344. The added explanation in the introduction has been included as to not mislead readers with the assumption that the Royal Navy had no admirals prior to 1707 instead of making it incredibly difficult for them to find them. This current list is in itself an antithesis to the hard work done by editors who have created interesting and dynamic biographies of officers who have now been cut off on a personal whim. Please remember this is a collaborative project and I respectfully asked people to change the date to 1660 but this was ignored despite me highlighting Ownership of content. Therefore this lack of collaboration has now left us with situation where a second and really quite unnecessary article will now have to be created in order to provided readers with a consistent chronological narrative of those officers appointed to the rank of Admiral of the Royal Navy by commission.--Navops47 (talk) 12:14, 21 February 2019 (UTC)
 * The evolution of understanding of what a rank is makes restricting the scope to post-Union admirals quite necessary, your personal whim notwithstanding.LE (talk) 20:57, 21 February 2019 (UTC)
 * If you believe that instead of keeping that information to yourself please enlighten me and direct me to verifiable sources that I can read and see for myself thank you.--Navops47 (talk) 08:22, 22 February 2019 (UTC)

Scope changes to this article to exclude consensus constitutes WP:Ownership of content
Originally the List of Royal Navy admirals was simply a list no dates assigned nor any description going back through the articles page history on https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision as of 19:40, 3 November 2017, https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision as of 20:36, 6 December 2017, https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision as of 17:58, 11 January 2018, https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision as of 19:39, 20 June 2018, https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision 01:10, 26 December 2018https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision as of 02:17, 29 December 2018, https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision at  01:03, 1 January 2019 that had no content therefore the scope was list Royal Navy admirals then on https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision as of 11:19, 4 January 2019 text content was added to change the scope of the article on the basis of promoted to the rank of admiral. Then https://en.wikipedia.org/Revision as of 23:22, 6 February 2019 the scope of the article was changed again to a political date thus cutting off any possiblity of Admirals promoted to the rank of Admiral prior to this date who would otherwise have been on it from 1660 the founding date of the Royal Navy. Despite numerous attempts with two other editors to reach consensus overs this my see previous objections in sections above goes against Ownership of content and in particluar Wikipedia:Ownership of content/Multiple-editor ownership This involvement of multiple editors, each defending the ownership to justify scope changes to the original list that did not consist of any rigid criteria in order to ignore my suggestions for the inclusion of Admirals from 1660 has fell on deaf ears.--Navops47 (talk) 07:55, 22 February 2019 (UTC)
 * There was a consensus until you disrupted it. Just when have you made efforts to reach a consensus other than one including the material only you have ever wanted included? LE (talk) 17:22, 22 February 2019 (UTC)
 * Its always sad when editors who have contributed a lot of work to an article cannot agree on its content. I am somewhat surprised that relevant projects were not notified to seek other interested and knowledgeable editors opinions. Reading through the history and looking at the article I feel that it is currently too long and should be split, my preference would be by centuries but I can accept splitting by dates of political entities but currently splitting out just the pre 1707 content I feel suggests that those individuals were in some way lesser admirals Lyndaship (talk) 11:36, 27 February 2019 (UTC)
 * Thanks for your feedback Lyndaship the reason I have not followed up with other project pages at this point is that both myself and the other two editors are also WP:Military History members and following on from some advice from a volunteer TransporterMan from the Dispute resolution noticeboard this morning they advised that the matter has to be discussed extensively on the talk page first before any complaint procedures about content ownership, content or editors is raised. Your suggestion about lists of RN admirals by century actually makes a lot of of sense and would be in line with some of the categorizations of admirals we have e.g. Category:17th-century Royal Navy personnel and Category:18th-century Royal Navy personnel and so on. Your comment about lesser admirals well these are some of the lesser admirals (without listing them all) were talking about: Sir Thomas Allin, 1st Baronet, John Ashby (Royal Navy officer), Matthew Aylmer, 1st Baron Aylmer, John Berry (Royal Navy officer), Robert Blake (admiral), George Churchill (Royal Navy officer), Stafford Fairborne, John Jennings (Royal Navy officer), William Penn (Royal Navy officer) notable enough to have their own biography's.--Navops47 (talk) 03:19, 28 February 2019 (UTC)

The edit history of this article shows pretty clearly that this article was being built up rapidly with assiduous work that was abandoned when Navops47 showed up and demanded that the evolution of understanding of what the rank of admiral means be disregarded.The pre-1707 admirals simply don't fit on a strictly ordered chronological list because the distinction between rank and appointment was not sufficiently developed.They need to be excluded from such a list.12.144.5.2 (talk) 00:31, 1 November 2019 (UTC)

Nelson
Guy's name shows up 50ish times on a page but he doesn't. I get that you want to exclude him because he didn't quite measure up rankwise. The article could still use a portrait with a note that he was only a whatever-admiral instead of good-enough-admiral. — Llywelyn II   18:43, 20 April 2024 (UTC)