Talk:List of Salt Lake City neighborhoods

Comments
Comment: This article was created based on a discussion at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Utah, and includes material split out from Salt Lake City and Buildings and sites of Salt Lake City articles. Those other articles may be edited down a little after this separate list-article is created. It is mostly based on use of the CityWeekly article that seems to be a great source. This list of neighborhoods has served in development of "Neighborhoods" column in National Register of Historic Places listings in Salt Lake City, Utah article. -- do ncr  am  01:25, 22 March 2013 (UTC)

Comment: Editor RadioFan declined this article with comment that having just a category would do; this view seems not to appreciate consensus view how lists and categories complement one another, e.g. as written up at wp:CLT. Here, there are red-links which, per policy on redlinks, promote the growth of wikipedia. Category cannot include red-links. Having the list identifies the neighbhorhoods. Etc. And, as discussed at Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Utah, this isn't a completely new article, it's intended to split out from an odd Buildings and sites of Salt Lake City article, which by its title does not naturally include neighborhoods. Lists of neighborhoods are standard articles: there currently are 52 entries in Category:Lists of neighborhoods in U.S. cities. I think this is a valid Wikipedia topic and moving this to mainspace would just help us get on with the task. :) -- do ncr  am  04:25, 11 June 2013 (UTC)