Talk:List of Trinitarian Universalists

I have removed Mary Carpenter, Lant Carpenter, and William Ellery Channing from this list. They were Unitarians and I'm sure would be most offended to be described as Trinitarians! Yewtree1968.

Disputed
The list seems to be based on this article http://www.tentmaker.org/tracts/Universalist.html. According to this document also Jesus, Paul and John were universalists. This is propaganda rather than scienctific writing. Theologist (talk) 14:39, 23 June 2008 (UTC)

Suggested removal of this article
In its present form this article does not come up to wikipedia's standards. There is only one rather dubious source, as observed above. Lists of persons can make sense as articles if their being on it in itself implies notability, as with lists of people who have received some honour. A list of persons who hold a particular belief, without regard for their notability, might need to have millions or even billions of entries. Clearly it only makes sense if it is restricted to notable people, who are properly identified. That means either, preferably, people who have wikipedia articles, with the links given, or people whose notability is clearly established by other means. If you compare it with List of Unitarians, Universalists, and Unitarian Universalists, the latter does meet this criterion, since nearly all of them are wikilinked.

So, is there someone out there, the originator of the article or otherwise, who is prepared to establish the links? Otherwise I'm inclined to propose the article for deletion in due course. SamuelTheGhost (talk) 18:03, 1 October 2008 (UTC)