Talk:List of caves of Alberta

There are alot of errors on this page. For example Canmore Caverns is entered twice, and it isn't even a cave - it is a guiding company. The Canadian Rockies do not 'run through' Alberta, the caves in Wood Buffalo are not in Alberta, etc.

Personally I'm not in favor of an Alberta cave list. I think (and I could be wrong), that these are intended to be lists of links to Wiki pages, and most Alberta caves do not really deserve their own Wiki page. There are at present only two caves listed under Canada (List of Caves) and only one of them has its own page. Also, you do not see a Somerset List or Derbyshire list for Britain, nor French lists by department, Mexican lists by state etc. Thoughts? Ian mckenzie 22:48, 2 March 2006 (UTC)


 * Do you think that the number of prominate caves in all of Canada could be easily contained in one article called List of caves in Canada? The article List of caves in the United States seems to manage all the famous American caves quite well. Once the Caves in Canada list is populated we can redirect the Alberta list there. --NormanEinstein 04:13, 3 March 2006 (UTC)
 * Agree. Despite being a larger country, Canada has only a tiny fraction of explored caves compared to the USA.  Of the ones known, only a handful (say, six or eight?) likely merit Wiki pages. I will ensure the caves with their own Wiki pages appear on the Canada list and then will replace the Alberta list with a redirect. I'm not sure whether small caves that do not even have their own stub should be included (tho I see them elsewhere).  AND, do we even need a page List of caves in Canada, or will the Canada entry on List of caves do?Ian mckenzie 21:19, 10 March 2006 (UTC)