Talk:List of hurdy-gurdy musicians

Brian David Gilbert Edit War
There appears to be an edit war over whether or not Brian David Gilbert should or should not be on this list. The primary source for this is This Video Showing him playing the Hurdy Gurdy. There is a note that this is an unreliable source and not justification for his inclusion. Why is a video of someone playing a Hurdy Gurdy not a reliable source proving that they can play it? (also why were all citations removed)

The fact of is that he demonstrated the ability to play the Hurdy Gurdy, which by my understanding of the word musician, means that Brian David Gilbert is a Hurdy Gurdy Musician & therefore should be included in this list. ColeShrop (talk) 23:59, 1 November 2023 (UTC)