Talk:List of people from Riverdale, Bronx

Categories
See Categorizing redirects. This allows an embedded list (subsection) to be categorised amongst similar lists (either embedded or not). It seems very useful to me. Occuli (talk) 14:43, 19 July 2008 (UTC)


 * I'm not going to fight over this, but this is the only redirect in that category, and there are dozens (at the least) of other cities and neighborhoods with similar embedded lists which do not have redirects linking to the category. Why should this list be special? In fact, it appears that you created the redirect specifically to add categories, since it's not something that was merged after a discussion. That was one of the primary reasons I removed the cats in the first place.
 * At least it's well-referenced, which is more than I can say most of the other lists in the category. Only two of the lists are fully referenced (List of people from Fort Lauderdale, Florida and List of people from Gainesville, Florida). List of people from Savannah, Georgia is mostly referenced; it has 117 references, with 17 people unreferenced.  Horologium  (talk) 15:25, 19 July 2008 (UTC)
 * I would create more but people keep deleting them ... I make no claims for the quality of the lists involved. Category:Lists of people by U.S. cities would be better if it did include all embedded lists (one can't sensibly say that Riverdale, Bronx is itself a list of people). (There was Category:People from Riverdale, Bronx which was deleted - hence the embedded list + the redirect.) Occuli (talk) 15:55, 19 July 2008 (UTC)