Talk:List of people of the Three Kingdoms (Z)

Too many Zhang Yi's?

There are fourteen different Zhang Yi's listed here and I'm not convinced they all exist. I suspect some of them are typos or mistranslations.

These ones are fine:

Zhang Yi : 張翼 	Bogong(伯恭) -- the Yi who was Administrator of Guanghan, accompanied Zhuge Liang on campaign in southern Yi and died during the Fall of Shu.

Zhang Yi : 張嶷 	Boqi(伯岐) -- the Yi who was Administrator of Yuexi

Zhang Yi : 張裔 	Junsi(君嗣) -- the Shu officer who was captured by Yong Kai and sent to Sun Quan

Zhang Yi : 張揖 	Zhirang(稚讓) -- the physician

Zhang Yi : 張顗 -- this is the Yi who served Yuan Shang then defected to Cao Cao (and fictionally, in the Sanguo Yanyi is killed by Gan Ning)

Zhang Yi : 張懌 -- son of Zhang Xian, who rebelled against Liu Biao and became a minor warlord in Changsha

Zhang Yi : 張逸 -- the Yongzhou officer who served under Liu Yu and died shortly after Gongsun Zan killed Liu Yu

Zhang Yi : 張異 -- the senior officer of Sun Quan who pacified the Mo camp in eastern Jiangxia

Zhang Yi : 張壹 -- this one seems like it is probably 張箷 (or 張懿, I'm not sure the exact characters), inspector of Bingzhou who was killed by the Xiongnu in 188. The 'Yi' character is changed in some texts because of the taboo against some characters during the Jin dynasty (because of Sima Yi).

That still leaves the following five:

Zhang Yi : 張怡

Zhang Yi : 張倚

Zhang Yi : 張懌

Zhang Yi : 張奕 (Jin)

Zhang Yi : 張奕 (Wu)

Anyone have any actual sources for these? I checked the Biographical Dictionary of Later Han and Three Kingdoms and none of them were listed. Are we sure they are not a mistranslated duplicate of the other Zhang Yi's or another error? — Preceding unsigned comment added by 192.75.88.231 (talk) 21:20, 4 August 2015 (UTC)