Talk:Love or Loved Part.1

What credits for Middle With You?
Where was Jordan Reifkind mentioned?

He's neither in the credits from KOMCA nor in the less precise ones from YouTube. I couldn't find the credits on any Korean plateform (at least not in the album's description).

- DriftingLill (talk) 23:55, 18 November 2022 (UTC)


 * I was wondering about the credits from the CD booklet, but he's apparently not there either.
 * Lyrics by B.I, Nick Lee, Jake Herring ; Composed by Nick Lee, Jake Herring ; Arranged by Nick Lee.


 * - DriftingLill (talk) 10:49, 20 November 2022 (UTC)
 * So... Both CD booklets actually give different composition credits. It's Nick Lee and Jake Herring for Card Pack, Nick Lee and Jordan Reifkind for Real Pack. In both case, only Nick Lee is credited for arrangement.
 * ASCAP and BMI have credits for "Middle With You" as well, and none of them mentions Jordan Reifkind. (B.I neither, though. I would assume these credits are for the demo version)
 * At this point, I think we should write "Lyrics by B.I, Nick Lee, Jake Herring ; Composed by Nick Lee, Jake Herring ; Arranged by Nick Lee" .
 * - DriftingLill (talk) 17:16, 28 November 2022 (UTC)
 * I got Jordan Reifkind from the credits here, but I agree with your final decision to write what's stated in the CD booklets. —Bostonite01310  talk ''' 04:14, 31 December 2022 (UTC)
 * Ok! I mentioned the booklet in the article, since there are actual differences depending on the source. Not sure if the KOMCA's references I added as well were necessary, but it's a trustworthy source, it's available online, and it does confirm most of the credits even if it's less precise for some songs.
 * - DriftingLill (talk) 15:46, 31 December 2022 (UTC)

Title of this article
Should we rename this article to Love or Loved Part.1? Since there is a lot of information on Part 1. Maybe Love or Loved Part.2 can be its own article. —Bostonite01310 talk ''' 17:38, 29 December 2022 (UTC)


 * I've been wondering as well, especially for the infobox (does it even work with two EPs?). And we would have to create "Love or Loved Part.1" et "Love or Loved Part.2" subsections everywhere, as I already did for the "Personnel" section... Separating Part.1 and Part.2 would make everything easier and clearer for everyone, I guess. We would need to rewrite the intro and probably put most of the info about the whole project in the "Background" section, but that's manageable?
 * I also think there's enough to say about "BTBT" to create a new article just for it, but it will take longer and won't solve everything. We can do both, anyway.
 * - DriftingLill (talk) 22:52, 29 December 2022 (UTC)


 * For two EPs I imagine it would be something like this -- Epik High Is Here. If there are two pages for Part.1 and Part.2, where should the Love or Loved page be redirected? —Bostonite01310  talk ''' 03:46, 31 December 2022 (UTC)
 * It does make the infobox harder to read. Actually, what bothers me the most is the chronology with the project name and the sole year 2021, whereas Part 2 was released in 2022. It's confusing, and we have the same issue with Love or Loved.
 * As for the redirection, I'm not sure. If B.I had a discography page, it could be have been redirected there, but he doesn't have one yet... It's strange to redirect it to B.I's main page at this point, when it barely mentions the project, but I think it should be more detailed anyway... (just for the sake of comparison, here is what I've written about it on B.I's French page)
 * Maybe we can redirect "Love or Loved" to Part.1's page for now, at least until Part.2's release? Then we'll see which page contains more information about the project?
 * - DriftingLill (talk) 01:09, 1 January 2023 (UTC)
 * OK. I moved the article now! Thanks for your inputs. —Bostonite01310  talk ''' 03:33, 1 January 2023 (UTC)