Talk:Maryam Abad, Gujranwala

Back to draft - note for AfC reviewers
I am a new page reviewer and I am sending this article back to draft for the second time. The topic of the article exists and there is at least one redlink in mainspace to Mariamabad.

The article was created by a user who was shortly afterwards blocked as a sockpuppet and was engaged in the creation of a run of geostubs on Pakistani towns. This seems to have been a factory-like approach to pushing up their edit count, because the articles are all original research, with mostly the same sources just cut and pasted into every article to give an appearance of sourcing when there is none.

In the current version of the article for example sources 1, 2 and 3 bear absolutely no resemblance to the points in the article they purport to verify. This article is a freestyle creative essay with a sprinkling of irrelevant sources to make it look acceptable.

Any volunteers working at AfC should review it very carefully and only accept it back into mainspace after a major clearout and rewrite. All the best Mccapra (talk) 05:12, 19 June 2020 (UTC)