Talk:Maspiro Massacre

Briefing on the recent violence in Egypt

Briefing on the recent violence in Egypt written and researched by the Alliance for a Democratic Egypt (www.allforegypt.org) and Better Life for Egypt (http://betterlifeforegypt.wordpress.com)

October 11, 2011

This past Sunday, the 9th of October, Egyptian citizens, including Muslims and Christians, gathered to protest the lack of disciplinary action taken by the Egyptian Government for the recent destruction of a church in Aswan. The sit- in protest resulted in military vehicles running over the peaceful protestors as a measure of containment, killing at least 24 unarmed civilians and injuring at least 300 more. The purpose of this brief is to clarify some of the facts that have been cloudy (or incorrect) in some media accounts in order to have a straight record as to the details of the events.

The peaceful protesters gathered in peaceful chants, angered by a statement made publicly by Aswan’s governor, Mustafa Kamel el-Sayyed, who, after the destruction of the church in Aswan, denied the existence of the church, and then later retracted his statements, and claimed instead that the construction of the Church was illegal. It was later revealed that extremist followers of the Salafist Islamic sect had pronounced threats and made demands for Aswan’s Christian congregation not to have any loudspeakers in the church and to limit the visibility of any Christian symbols such as crosses on the church structure. In order to diffuse tensions, the Aswan governorate organized a meeting between Salafist and Coptic leaders, wherein the Copts refused the latter demand of eliminating crosses and steeples. The threats eventually escalated to actual destruction of the church by the extremists, and to the subsequent statements by the Aswan governor. It was this incident that led to the protest, which is presented in the following details based on a number of credible sources[1]:

The march set out towards Maspiro from the downtown poverty-stricken neighborhood of Shubra, densely populated by both Muslims and Christians. Reporters agree that it was a sizeable demonstration comparable to the numbers at the January 28 protest, the day when Mubarak sent army vehicles to confront protesters[2]. Protesters were also angry about injury sustained by a Christian priest during the violent confrontation by army and police at Wednesday’s demonstration at Maspiro, when a smaller group had been demonstrating against the situation in Aswan.

Reports suggest that the army began using violence even before the protesters reached Maspiro. Gunshots were heard from the end of Shubra Street and rocks were thrown from a nearby bridge. The protesters responded in chants against the Field Commander. The attacks suddenly stopped as the protesters proceeded on Galaa Street. As they crossed the Al Ahram headquarters, one rock was thrown at the building. Reports suggest this was in response to Al Ahram’s poor coverage of violence against Copts in a recent issue.

Army attacks resumed when the protesters turned the corner at Ramsis Hotel and reached Maspiro. Witnesses saw two armored personnel carriers crushing protesters to death, and soldiers firing wildly at the congregation, followed by riot police throwing tear gas. These incidents have been documented by video and later broadcast on CNN[3]. Reports count between 24 and 27 deaths, mostly Coptic civilians, and over 300 injured.

State television within minutes of violence first reported the death of three soldiers and requested that all noble Egyptian patriots protect the military against the “violent crowd of Copts,” also alluding to “foreign infiltrators” inciting violence. Eye witness reports which are attached to this brief, describe the response to the televised announcement by crowds of Muslims zealous to protect the military against allegedly violent Copts: “I saw groups in civilian clothing with sticks and machetes walking around yelling ‘Where are the Christians? Islam is here!’”[4] This eyewitness stated he fled the scene as various crowds asked him whether or not he was a Christian. That evening, state television continued to broadcast a manipulated version of the story claiming the protesters were armed and that a “conflict” had broken out between civilians and military personnel with riot police, leaving deaths and injuries on both sides. Later, the Department of Health released another statement indicating that there were no military deaths and associating all bodies with deceased civilian protesters.

Several international media outlets, including BBC and CNN, picked up this version of the events. Egyptian state television later retracted the fabrications when it broadcast a mild report on the events the following day, but continued to exhibit a reluctance to condemn the actions of the army[5].

Public figures, including prominent Muslim and Coptic leaders, have demanded the prosecution of army generals. The military council then called for the civilian Prime Minister to investigate the incident and identified 15 suspects to be tried in military courts. The military council and state television remain targets of heated criticism from prominent activists and journalists. The representatives at the state television have not issued any statements, but a newscaster has publicly expressed feeling “ashamed” to be working for an institution that “[proved] itself to be a slave for whoever rules Egypt.”[6] Activists also blame state television for provoking sectarian tensions.

Governor Mustafa Kamel El Sayyed reportedly said that the demolition of the Church was agreed to by the local Coptic community and absolved himself of any responsibility in the tragic events at Maspiro[7]. The Ministerial Cabinet announced it will amend laws pertaining to the construction of houses of worship and toughen the anti-discrimination laws, but local human rights activists doubt the effectiveness or follow-through of the Cabinet’s approach[8]. Identical promises have been made following other similar incidents (recently and in the more distant past) without any follow-through to amend the archaic laws that differentially govern construction of houses of worship.

[1] Carr, Sarah. “A First-Hand Account: Marching from Shubra to Deaths at Maspiro” Al Masry Al Youm. October, 10, 2011. http://www.almasryalyoum.com/en/node/503496

[2] Blair, Edmund. “Egypt’s Mubarak sends in army, resists demands to quit” Reuters. January 28, 2011. http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/01/28/us-egypt-protest-idUSTRE70O3UW20110128

[3] Mackey, Robert. “Social Media Accounts of Violence in Cairo Challenge Official Narrative.” The New York Times. October 10, 2011. http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/10/10/social-media-accounts-of-violence-in-cairo-challenge-official-narrative/

[4] Bushra, Hani. “My testimony about the attack I suffered in downtown Cairo on October 9, 2011” Facebook. October 9, 2011. https://www.facebook.com/notes/hani-bushra/my-testimony-about-the-attack-that-i-suffered-in-downtown-cairo-on-october-9-201/10150321526196820

[5] Ammar, Manar. “Egypt state television admits to making up news over soldiers’ deaths” Bikya Masr. October 10, 2011. http://bikyamasr.com/45280/egypt-state-television-admits-to-making-up-news-over-soldiers-deaths/

[6] El Gundy, Zeinab. “Outrage over state TV’s misinformation and anti-Coptic incitement” Ahram Online. October 10, 2011. http://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/1/64/23813/Egypt/Politics-/Outrage-over-state-TVs-misinformation-and-antiCopt.aspx

[7] Free Christian Voice. October 11, 2011. http://www.light-dark.net/vb/showthread.php?p=8127#post8127

[8] Fahmy, Heba. “Experts say tougher measures needed after Maspero, slam state media coverage” The Daily News Egypt. October 11, 2011. http://www.thedailynewsegypt.com/egypt/experts-say-tougher-measures-needed-after-maspero-slam-media-coverage.html --67.83.76.216 (talk) 04:32, 21 October 2011 (UTC)