Talk:Moaning (band)

Untitled
I do not understand why you declined my submission. As far as I can see, it definitely meets Criterion 1 of musical notability - sources include a well-known newspaper and arguably one of national record (the Los Angeles Times) and well-known sources that meet the reliability criteria as specified in the "Wikipedia: Reliable sources" page. Albeit most of the sources could be considered primary but they satisfy the criteria laid out in the aforementioned page for primary sources. Please let me know either how exactly you disagree with the assertion I've just put forth or let me know how to get to the point of this article's publication on Wikipedia at your earliest convenience. Thank you.

Ross Moody 7-5-2020

I've changed and added some reliable secondary sources, which now include The Irish Times and Stereogum. I also forgot to note the inclusion of a citation of an article from LA Weekly, which is a leading alternative newsweekly. Finally, having it brought to my attention from another editor, it appears that the band meets criterion 5 - they have two releases on Sub Pop, which matches the description of an "independent label with a history of more than a few years, and with a roster of performers, many of whom are independently notable" as specified in criterion 5.

Ross Moody 7-7-2020

Checking In
Hi,

I am just checking in on this as it has been more than 2 months since I re-submitted this article for review with the changes I made after it was initially declined.

I would appreciate any information/feedback regarding whether or not it will be accepted or what further changes need to be made before could possibly be accepted.

I appreciate your attention and consideration very much.

Thank you,

Rossmoody88 (talk) 06:31, 13 September 2020 (UTC) Ross Moody