Talk:Moscow Villa Hut

Importance
I am not familiar with this hut. It is however a verifiable place. For example, http://www.lcool.org/trips/new_year_high_tom_groggin/tom_groggin.html

Noted in passing while searching this photo link of Bill Ah Chow http://www.chia.chinesemuseum.com.au/biogs/CH00894b.htm

The Australian Alps article states: ''Within the Australian Alps there are 120 still active alpine huts that mainly originate from the early cattlemen days. Many have remained in use by hikers and skiing groups throughout the year. Most of these huts are maintained by volunteers through the Kosciuszko Huts Association and the local National Parks services.

''Some of the more famous huts include Moscow Villa Hut, Valentine Hut, and Mawsons Hut. In recent years many huts have been lost through lack of maintenance and bush fire. An example of that is the Pretty Plain Hut which was lost in the Bushfires of 2003.''

I wouldn't mind a citation for the "most famous" assertion. However, the place is verifiable and is illustrative of alpine huts. On these grounds I think the article should remain.--A Y Arktos\talk 21:15, 16 June 2006 (UTC)

Anther verification http://www.kosciuskohuts.org.au/Hut%20Profiles%20VIC/Profile%20Moscow%20Villa.htm but I fail to see what is notable about it, there are another 120 huts out there each with about as much notability as this one. ...maelgwntalk 01:21, 11 January 2007 (UTC)

Deletion
Although i support the deletion of this article, it creates a precedent for deleting basically every Australian hut article. This is based around the notability of each hut. What makes a hut notable? There is an article out there about every Formula One car race each season, which to me seem less notable than any hut that is more than a toilet. What would we try and provide in any hut article that may be created?

Why doesn't this go to AfD? ...maelgwntalk 09:07, 20 January 2007 (UTC)


 * You may contest the proposed deletion by simply removing the box. In that case, I am certain someone (like me) will bring to AfD. You may also contest the proposed deletion and bring it to AfD yourself, if you feel like it. Jobjörn  (Talk ° contribs) 11:49, 23 January 2007 (UTC)