Talk:Naoko (novel)

Incorrect Link
The link to the actor Kaoru Kobayashi on the page is incorrect. The pages [Kaoru Kobayashi] and [Kaoru Kobayashi (actor)] are different people. The link on the page goes to [Kaoru Kobayashi], but it should go to [Kaoru Kobayashi (actor)] —Preceding unsigned comment added by 218.224.158.157 (talk) 12:41, 20 December 2010 (UTC)

Identity crisis
The page seems to be suffering a little. It claims to be about the novel yet the infobox is for the film.

Most of the detail is about the film. Can we discuss what to do about it?


 * 1) Two pages: one for the Japanese novel and the Japanese film; one for The Secret remake.
 * 2) Two pages: one for the novel; one for both films.
 * 3) Three pages: one for the novel, one for Himitsu (1992 film), one for The Secret.

Personally I think the only real option is three pages. The novel won an award, the original film a nomination in Japan and Catalonian awards, the remake did not do so well. Chaosdruid (talk) 22:37, 9 March 2012 (UTC)