Talk:Naresh Kalwaniya

Contest deletion: Asiad medallist passes Notability criteria on 3 counts
I thanks Rowing007 (talk · contribs) for taking the trouble to review all the Indian rowing medallists pages I created as part of the India Project. All the BLPs pass the Notabillity criteria, as any top-8 of the Continental championships are considered noteworty for a wiki page. But these are excelled and are medal winners. 100 other profiles with same criteria are created during Asian Games for medallists. So I request that the page be retained. Oppose deletion. Rowing007 has also deleted Career sections of all the rowers, where I have cited, reliable, reputed secondary news sources for every event, but he has cited no reason for deleting the entire section. I hope he reviews and notes a valid reason, and hope other editors review again. Some Start class, as reviewed by other experienced editors, became stubs after chunks of info was deleted without any reasonable explanation. thanks David. Davidindia (talk) 16:29, 31 October 2023 (UTC)