Talk:Nasser Gul Ghaman

move justified with a misleading edit summary
It seems to me this article was moved in a move justified with a misleading edit summary, namely: "The old name is mostly based on the older primary sources. The new one is based on the secondary sources specially the NYT's". This edit summary implies the NYTimes said it based the transliteration of the name it chose as the primary name for this captive after conducting some research, or consulting an expert. In fact, the NYTimes did no such thing. Every name the picked is one used on the older documents the contributor who moved this article has decried. It seems they arbitrarily picked one from among the several names. I regard it as misleading to imply NYTimes choice is different than the "older documents".

FWIW I have asked the contributor to explain why he called the OARDEC memos "primary documents", when they are summaries based on the independent collation, analysis, and summaries of other reports from other agencies. I don't believe I have received a meaningful answer so far.

Normally I wouldn't leave a note on like this on every page changed in a series of changes. Normally I would leave a note on that contributors talk page. But this contributor has requested me to leave the note on every article's talk pages. Geo Swan (talk) 14:26, 24 December 2009 (UTC)


 * There is nothing misleading in my edit summary at all. The only misleading thing is your post here. I really wonder - Have you checked the new name in secondary sources? You can not leave messages regarding content issues on my talk page? That is wrong. You are welcome. You have done that frequently just in the last couple of days and i have answered you every post or question regarding content issues. Abour the OARDEC documents i have explained that to you here and never got an answer from you.


 * Could you please provide me with the sources for this name? And could you please provide with the rational that these sources are the most reliable one? And if multiple source had been use for the creation of this name. How did the editor who created the name combined the sources to come up with a new name and why did he do it that way. This is an ongoing event. More and more reliable secondary sources are now available. We should use them all to chose the right name. Thank's in advance. IQinn (talk) 15:26, 24 December 2009 (UTC)

Pages that linked to "Nasser Gul Ghaman"
User:Geo Swan/working/new official names as of May 15 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/working/Summary of Evidence memos ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/deletion watch ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/List of Guantanamo Bay detainees/ISN 1000-1463 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/List of Guantanamo Bay detainees/ISN union ‎ (links) Guantanamo captive 1037 (redirect page) ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/ARB transcript list ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/September2007/arb2 transcripts ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/September2007/Index to Unclassified Summaries of Evidence for Combatant Status Review Tribunals Held at Guantanamo Between July 2004 and July 2007 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/September2007/union ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/List of Guantanamo captives who went through the complete CSRT process ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Captives interviewed by McClatchy News Service ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/20060618 seizure captives ‎ (links) Talk:Guantanamo Bay detention camp/Archive 2 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Guantanamo captives list of release dates ‎ (links) Timeline of the release and transfer of Guantanamo Bay detainees ‎ (links) Chaman Nazargul (redirect page) ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/September2007/arb2 transcripts ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/September2007/Index to Unclassified Summaries of Evidence for Combatant Status Review Tribunals Held at Guantanamo Between July 2004 and July 2007 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/September2007/union ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/List of Guantanamo captives who went through the complete CSRT process ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Afghan captives in Guantanamo ‎ (links) Nazar Chaman Gul (redirect page) ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Captives interviewed by McClatchy News Service ‎ (links) Nazul Gul (redirect page) ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/20060618 seizure captives ‎ (links) Afghan detainees at Guantanamo Bay ‎ (links) ISN 1037 (redirect page) ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/List of Guantanamo Bay detainees/by ID number ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Afghan captives in Guantanamo ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Captives interviewed by McClatchy News Service ‎ (links) Afghan detainees at Guantanamo Bay ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Guantanamo captives list of release dates ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Arb release decision dates ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/inprocess dates ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/inprocess dates ISN and names ‎ (links) Timeline of the release and transfer of Guantanamo Bay detainees ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/list/May 15 2006 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Individual OARDEC by ISN ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/DoD official Guantanamo captives' list 2006-05-15 ‎ (links) User talk:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/DoD official Guantanamo captives' list 2006-05-15 ‎ (links) NASSER GUL GHAMAN (redirect page) ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/inprocess dates ISN and names ‎ (links) Nazargul Chaman (redirect page) ‎ (links) List of Guantanamo Bay detainees ‎ (links) Hezb-e-Islami Gulbuddin ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/working/official Guantanamo names ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/working/Guantanamo articles I started ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/working/detainees who went through their CSRT ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/working/detainees guide ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/working/detainees guide 2 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/test ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/List of Guantanamo Bay detainees/by ID number ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/List of Guantanamo Bay detainees/ISN 1000-1463 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/List of Guantanamo Bay detainees/ISN union ‎ (links) Wikipedia:WikiProject Military history/Assessment/Drive/131 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Taliban Bounty list ‎ (links) Wikipedia:WikiProject Persondata/List of biographies/8 ‎ (links) User:Dsp13/Living people needing categorization by year of birth/5 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Afghan captives in Guantanamo ‎ (links) Talk:Guantanamo Bay detention camp/Archive 2 ‎ (links) User:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Guantanamo captives list of release dates ‎ (links) Talk:David Frum/Archive 1 ‎ (links) User:Pascal666/living/2 ‎ (links) User talk:Geo Swan/Guantanamo/Master list of GWOT articles I have started ‎ (links) Timeline of the release and transfer of Guantanamo Bay detainees ‎ (links) Wikipedia:WikiProject Terrorism/Guantanamo captives' names ‎ (links) User:Star Garnet/Gitmo ‎ (links) Wikipedia:WikiProject Terrorism/Guantanamo captives' names ‎ (links) User:BirgitteSB/Priority BLP ‎ (links) Wikipedia:WikiProject Afghanistan/Cleanup listing ‎ (links) User:Tony Sidaway/Living people/tranche 031 ‎ (links)