Talk:Non-Zionism

Problem - there is more than one meaning of the term
This is the first time I have seen this meaning of the term. However, there is another meaning which is rather widely used, which is for a religious Jew who does not consider himself a Zionist (that is, a Chareidi), but is not anti-Zionist. (This group would consider itself pro-Israel, but so would many religious anti-Zionists.)

However, this is unrelated to the definition in the article, because this group does make Aliyah (as do religious anti-Zionists and even the small group of religious anti-Israel people). I will give myself as example, a non-Zionist and patriotic Israeli citizen, who fulfilled a lifelong dream to make Aliyah two years ago. Then we have Chabad (Lubavich) Chassidim, Sanz-Kloisenberg Chassidim (who occupy a large area of Netanya, complete with the Laniado hospital), and countless others. How can we merge this in?

(Yes, of course we need cites. Besides that, although cites are welcome, since they are harder to get here is Israel :-))Mzk1 (talk) 18:14, 23 February 2010 (UTC)

i thought non-zionism was having a neutral viewpoint on this conflict
here's some non-zionist(not to be confused) stances on this conflict

1.the world should leave them alone, and let the palestnians and the jews solve this conflict on their own. let them duke it out on each other and then side with the winner of the war.

2.it doesn't matter who the land should belong to, since nations are "social constructs"

3.that land should be an anarchist state — Preceding unsigned comment added by Crossovershipper (talk • contribs) 04:56, 14 December 2011 (UTC)

I added a part about Simon Dubnow
I added a section about Simon Dubnow as I think his political influence on non-Zionism is not to be understated. That said, if anyone wants to add to this section, I'd be more than happy to see my ideas added on to, or maybe see the section expanded to include other factors as well. In any case, this is just a thought. 140.141.4.65 (talk) 04:58, 30 April 2024 (UTC)