Talk:Panchpargania language

Merge
Panchpargania language and Kurmali language are two different language of Jharkhand state in India. Though lexical similarity and area spoken intersect with each other yet each of the two languages have separate identity. If required, selective merger of selected part from both separate articles may be done without redirecting. Seperate title and articles are required so that this articles may be further improved and/or more useful information may be added with correct citations and references.


 * Both articles say these may be the same language. This is s.t. we should try to resolve. If they are mutually intelligible but have distinct social identities, that would affect their classification. — kwami (talk) 19:25, 10 October 2012 (UTC)

Please refer to existing article on Bihari languages in wikipedia by which list of languages in the group Bihari Language is furnished depicting the Kudmali language having No. of speakers 37,000 whereas Panchpargania speaking people are 274,000. Also, their Scripts and Geographical Distribution is mentioned in the same article. Therefore, both the languages may be allowed to be accessed under different articles. Hence, present merger may be discontinued on the above grounds. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Ppramanik (talk • contribs) 13:21, 19 July 2013 (UTC)


 * WP is not a ref for WP. They have separate ISO codes, but so do lots of lects which are not really separate languages.  — kwami (talk) 00:40, 20 July 2013 (UTC)