Talk:Paris Saint-Germain F.C.

Squad
So the pre-season have ended and the new season have started. We are yet to know how the 'first team' would 'look like' from the official website. There is no confirmation about 'elite squad' like last season either. In this scenario, what do you all think 'other players under contract' should look like? This is my personal opinion with the players currently listed in the page.

Gharbi - U19 career is over and looks like to be part of first team. Also featured in league matchday squad. Should stay in current squad section.

Kurzawa - loan return, featured in matchday squad. Stay in current squad section.

Draxler, Dagba, Michut, Nagera, Wijnaldum - back from loan, yet to be named in matchday squad in official match. Dont think any of them in coach's plans. Should be in other players under contract section

Nhaga, E.Mbappe, Lemina - they were part of preseason tour. Unless they are going to be part of elite squad, they should be only named in the reserves & youth academy page. Not in main page. Yes, they are under pro contract but also eligible to play for U19 team, where they'll mainly play

Mouquet, Randriamany, Fernandez, Bodiang, Muntu Wa Mungu - U19 career is over and wont be part of first team dynamics. Proper 'other players under contracts' players.

Tagging usual contributors User:Paul Vaurie and User:DroopyDoggy to know opinions.

Kokoeist (talk) 22:06, 16 August 2023 (UTC)
 * I agree with all of what you stated up here. For their inclusion in the most recent squad, Zaïre-Emery, Gharbi, and Kurzawa should be in the current squad section for me, along with Navas. About Draxler, although he was on the Japan tour and was assigned a number, he was not on the team last year and didn't make the recent squad, and should be in the "other players" section. Mouquet is now a senior player just like Gharbi, and was also included in the Japan tour, but he has never appeared in a squad, so I would keep him in the "other players" section. Then we have the cases of Nhaga, Housni, Lemina, and E. Mbappé. All of them participated in the Japan tour, and received squad numbers. However, apparently the first three were sent back to train with the U19s upon their return in France, while E. Mbappé stayed in first-team training. Housni is the only one to have made an official first-team appearance. I think that sending them back to the U19s based on the media report creates updating problems, and it raises a question about what Housni's appearances last season mean now. My personal opinion is that until the "elite group" and/or the first-team squad drops, we should just keep Nhaga, Housni, E. Mbappé, and Lemina in the "other players under contract" section. It would complicate our life if we didn't, because then we have to follow media reports and make rules and exceptions that don't make sense. Since they're already here, let's just keep them here for now until we get PSG's official squad. Lastly, Randriamamy, Bodiang, Dagba, Fernandez-Veliz, Muntu Wa Mungu, Michut, Wijnaldum, and Nagera are all first-team players not included in the Japan tour or the recent squad this season, and should thus be in the other players section. Essentially, my conclusion is that right now, nothing needs to be changed. We should wait for the official squad to drop to make according changes. Paul Vaurie (talk) 22:41, 16 August 2023 (UTC)
 * Short Verison: While You Guys Are Right. PSG Should Be Scared for the Future.
 * Long Version: For The Most Part. You Guys Are Correct. But PSG Should be Scared About the Future. Messi Left for the U.S.A. Neymar was Sold To Saudi Arabia. They are Soon Going to Lose Mbappe in July 2024. Not to Mention that they had to Cut Players and Management for Said Players and More. Over 11 Players were put on transfer List! If we Can Learn Anything From This. It's that you Have to Start Small. And Grow from that. Teams like Real Madrid, Bayern Munich, Inter Milan. And Barcelona Start like That. Recently We Saw Sevilla Win The Euorpa League and Put up A Good Fight Against Manchester City In the Super Cup. You Need to Start Small and Grow The Foundation from there or else You'll Crumble. The Problem is that PSG Never Got to Start Like That Because At the Start They Overspent on Players and Almost Went Bankrupt. With The QSI Buying Them Being Their One Saving Grace. And After. They Kept Spending On Big Name Players. And it All Came Crashing Down After 2021. Orange Anomaly. (talk) 00:33, 24 August 2023 (UTC)

Dangling modifier/Non-parallel comparison
''Considered the club's golden era, the Parisians won nine trophies and reached five consecutive European semi-finals during the. . .''

This sentence starts out describing an era, but immediately following the comma, where the specified era should be, there is instead "the Parisians." This is a classic dangling modifier grammatical error. The sentence should instead read:

In what was considered the club's golden era, the Parisians won. . . 2600:1700:5B2C:A090:8C2C:5BAD:F790:E967 (talk) 16:11, 19 September 2023 (UTC)