Talk:Paul Noel Fiorino/GA1

GA Review
The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.''

Dr. Swag Lord: Dr.Swag Lord, Ph.d (talk · contribs) Hi, I'll review this. 01:07, 11 July 2024 (UTC)

Main concern 1: The short length of the article trigged some alarm bells for me. After doing a very basic search, I realized there are plenty of sources available the nominator could have used to broaden the article. Sources not used include:. As of now, the article is clearly not broad enough for GA standards.

Main concern 2: I'm seeing way too many questionable sources used. This is a BLP which requires high-quality sources. Questionable sources include:


 * Ballot Access News: while authored by Richard Winger, you can not use a WP:SPS in a BLP
 * A Tweet by some random person
 * northernexpress.com: Using an opinion article for facts
 * Vote Smart (cited 4 times): Per prior consensus, Vote Smart is fine for things like the subject's voting record or whatnot, but this article is not using the source in such a way
 * Independent Political Report (cited 2 times): This source was once part of the project's large scale clean-up efforts since it was deemed unreliable

Other concerns:


 * " however, he was the first independent candidate to ever appear on a Colorado gubernatorial ballot." --that's WP:OR using a primary source
 * The infobox notes he has two children which is not sourced in the article
 * The infobox notes he is the President of the Golden Triangle Museum District which is not sourced in the article

All-in-all, I believe this article qualifies for a WP:QF since it's a long way from meeting multiple GA criteria. Good luck on improving the article in the future! Dr. Swag Lord (talk) 01:29, 11 July 2024 (UTC)


 * On a post-review note, while it appears this review was done in haste, I actually had this article saved on my computer for sometime, debating if I should review it or not. Rest assured, I spent the necessary amount of time examining it. Dr. Swag Lord (talk) 01:32, 11 July 2024 (UTC)