Talk:Pokemon Gold and Silver Remake

Delete this article?
I say this article is completely useless.

1. A lot of information in this article is incorrect. For example, the S.S. Anne Ticket never appeared in any game other than Diamond and Pearl (it was always called the "S.S. Ticket"); furthermore, the S.S. Anne didn't appear in G/S/C anyway (that was the S.S. Aqua).

2. Non-notable. The G/S/C remake movement is completely fan-driven, has never made it out of a forum, and doesn't have as much support as the SOVA campaign did during its brief lifespan.

3. Pure speculation. There's been absolutely no hint by either Nintendo or Game Freak to make a remake of G/S/C. "several websites have discused" (they haven't, except on forums) and "Hints of a remake have been mentioned in multiple Pokémon games" (no examples given). What's more, it says vaguely that these hints were prominent in FR/LG, but... they weren't. In fact, I can't think of any.

I say this should be deleted... EllipsesBent 20:18, 20 December 2006 (UTC)


 * The administrator A Man in Black replaced this page with a redirect to Pokémon Gold and Silver, and you (essentially) accused him of vandalism, then restored the article. I'd just like to point out that putting the warning on the article and then editing the article makes it easy for him not to see it (I didn't even notice it until I went through the page history). You'd be better off putting the comment on people's talk pages in the future.

I've put a delete template in this article, by the way. This belongs on Bulbapedia, not here. EllipsesBent 22:26, 24 December 2006 (UTC)