Talk:Reuel Marc Gerecht

Untitled
Dear Mr Gerecht, your Article in the WSJ about CIA work needed in Syria, I think is correct. The CIA needs to help the Free Syrian Movement to prevent more bloodshed to innocent cilivans. Shipments of RPGs, Canadian fired antitank rockets, M2 browning 50 cal guns, and M16s, plus medical kits and food. Some SFGs to assist infantry platoon and company training would also be helpful. Please put me om your blog list ericpalmer@suddenlink.net, thanks Eric Palmer

Untitled
this Wiki entry includes ad hominem attacks, and overlooks providing substantiating links (ie Bernard Lewis' supposed objections to Gerecht and his viewpoints).

needs editing.

75.68.171.230 17:08, 28 March 2007 (UTC)

Removal of bogus & libellous hoax edits
Holy crap. Doesn't anybody have this page watchlisted??!!! That was some of the most blatant garbage I've ever seen in Wikipedia that wasn't immediately deleted by the first editor to come across it. It sat there for 2 entire weeks -- and it would still be there if I hadn't stumbled on it, purely by chance. Unbelievable. Cgingold 03:11, 7 April 2007 (UTC)

Ditto. Isn't this supposed to be a definition appearing in an "encyclopedia"? Then why does it include a value judgment? Take for instance the remark about the subject being "hawkish" on Iran. When definitions include personal value judgments, the whole idea of objectivity goes out the window. If such a remark were even relevant, why isn't it attributed to a source? Put into quotation marks? It is stated as fact. That undercuts the credibility not just of this entry but of Wikipedia in general, and it ought to be monitored, though I wonder if most who are involved know the difference.JessWestTx (talk) 21:37, 23 November 2009 (UTC)

Us centric language
The term "living abroad" is not suitable and underspecified for this Lemma and Wikipedia in general. You mean "outside the United States". Please also add a birth date and a credible biographic source. Otherwise this Lemma is a deletion candidate. --Rebentisch (talk) 14:02, 17 June 2019 (UTC)