Talk:Richmond (provincial electoral district)

Change to DAB
can you please explain why you reverted my changes. Richmond (provincial electoral district) needs to be disambiguated and doing so directly on this page is more precise and clear than doing so on a relatively large dab pages of all places named Richmond. MB 15:38, 9 December 2016 (UTC)
 * In short: Consensus about how to handle incomplete disambiguation cases. That's why this page contained Incomplete disambiguation before it became a redirect. I see no reason why this case should be handled differently than the 20,000+ other redrects. If you think that the current redirect to the Canada section is unclear, then the solution is to make the 'main' disambiguation page "Richmond" clearer, not forking it partially. LittleWink (talk) 16:49, 9 December 2016 (UTC)
 * I think that it's the title that is really wrong. I would prefer the title to have been Richmond Provincial Electoral District, which is naturally disambiguated (from other Richmonds) per WP:NATURALDIS, the same way there is Richmond School District instead of  Richmond (School District).


 * But that seems to be how all the Canadian provincial election districts were named and I didn't want to MOVE them all. So I proceeded in improving the navigation as if the title did not use parens as a compromise.MB 17:21, 9 December 2016 (UTC)