Talk:Sacred Heart Catholic Church


 * ''The following discussion has concluded. Please do not modify this section. Result of discussion: Merge.

proposed merge
Someone put a proposed merge tag on this article. To the someone, would you please use "mergeto" tag on this article, and please add "mergefrom" tag on article that you propose as target of the merge, to give notice properly to both places, and to direct editors to discuss at one place. You can explicitly set a parameter to indicate where the Talk should take place.

The current "Sacred Heart Catholic Church" dab is good in that it disambiguates between places of that proper noun name, and it also covers one or two with "Roman Catholic" rather than just "Catholic" in that. I don't totally oppose merging it with another church dab page, but why? This one covers the places of exactly this name. Some church dabs are huge and cover too many variations of church names. "Sacred Heart church" is not even a proper name for a dab page. I believe there are zero places of exactly that name (probably it should be moved to "Sacred Heart Church").

Thanks for opening this discussion by at least setting up the proposal tag. Feel free to actually state your support for your intended merge, here! :) -- do ncr  am  14:57, 1 August 2011 (UTC)
 * There was nothing in this article that wasn't already in the other article, so I just redirected it.-- SarekOfVulcan (talk) 15:10, 1 August 2011 (UTC)
 * Ah. Didn't realize it was only moved over a week ago. I'll leave the redirect for now, but this is definitely worth continuing discussion.-- SarekOfVulcan (talk) 15:15, 1 August 2011 (UTC)
 * If all, or almost all, of the places actually named Sacret Heart Catholic Church are in the U.S., then I tend to think keeping a separate dab is better for serving readers. The U.S. section that is way down in the Sacred Heart church dab can include a hatnote / see also link to this dab page, with mention that there are many U.S. churches named this, and the items copied to there recently could be removed from there, so maintenance is easier.  That's what i think is best, currently.  No one should have any too strong opinions about this, it should just be about serving readers and editors. -- do  ncr  am  17:02, 1 August 2011 (UTC)


 * Well, I did not even remember why this page was on my watch list. Now I realized there is Structured gallery of Sacred Heart churches which I had started some time ago and then forgotten to complete. The merge issue just made me remember it exists. There should probably be a link to that Commons gallery as well, I don't know why I did not add that. Overall I would support merging the Wikipages all together and somehow grouping them via Cathedral vs Church etc on one page as sections, or marking them somehow. The current system is just too disorganized. But anyway, probably by the end of the ear I will finish that Commons gallery too, and often those galleries will be larger than the lists here, and eventually using the images pages may be built for each. As you can see here are plenty in Germany with images, but no entries here, etc. And I just happened to work on Germany then, I do not remember why. But there are probably many more in France than one may imagine. But it will take a lot of time, maybe well into 2012 to do it. I will try do one or two every day from now. And one day, one day, there will be a Wolfram alpha type system below all this and these issues will be redundant, but until then, the more centralization, the better. History2007 (talk) 19:29, 1 August 2011 (UTC)


 * No discussion for 2 weeks. I guess we can either wait another week, or if you guys feel like merging them now, please do. As I added more to the Commons gallery, I realized that this page is pretty incomplete - e.g. nothing in Canada, etc. But that is another story. History2007 (talk) 08:18, 16 August 2011 (UTC)


 * I think we should just merge these anyway now that there is no debate. I will try to get around to it, else please just do it as they say. History2007 (talk) 07:46, 5 November 2011 (UTC)