Talk:Sam Giles

PROD removed
PROD concern: "Although the individual has published a few good academic papers, by comparison with other high profile academics in the field of palaeontology (for example, Jenny Clack, Mark Norell or Michael Benton), her contribution is very minor. I feel that maybe in the future this individual should be considered for a wiki page, but at present I cannot see any reason for it being retained. The research section also boasts of self promotion and several of the references are directly linked to academic studies, rather than actual newsworthy science. My suggestion is for the page to be considered for deletion." PROD added by new editor user:Xioa72, and is their only edit to date. PROD is not appropriate for discussing whether an article should be deleted - that is done through WP:AFD. RebeccaGreen (talk) 05:14, 20 December 2018 (UTC)