Talk:Scientific-Humanitarian Committee

Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
This article was the subject of a Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment, between 2 February 2021 and 16 May 2021. Further details are available on the course page. Student editor(s): JTatreau.

Above undated message substituted from Template:Dashboard.wikiedu.org assignment by PrimeBOT (talk) 08:47, 17 January 2022 (UTC)

History
"It was the first such organisation in history." Do we know this for a fact, or just that it was the first in modern history? In ancient Greece, for instance, isn't it likely there were groups promoting the acceptance of homosexuality (which was not always the case)? --MQDuck (talk) 21:00, 21 November 2007 (UTC)


 * The idea of such a group in ancient Greece is, I think, extremely anachronistic. Take a look at Homosexuality in ancient Greece. Ideas about sexuality in ancient Greece were very different from those of our time.


 * Before a group promoting the acceptance of homosexuality might exist, there should be a concept, a definition of homosexuality, a psychologic identification. However difficult to understand for modern man, the ancient Greek had no such concept, definition or identification. Soczyczi (talk) 19:27, 24 November 2007 (UTC)

"This book, and other that may have survived the destruction of the Wissenschaftlich-humanitäres Komitee and the Institut für Sexualwissenschaft, are sought after by the Magnus-Hirschfeld-Gesellschaft in Berlin." What book is this referring to? The source refers to several different books. Also, shouldn't this be in the "Publications" section? — Preceding unsigned comment added by 67.201.255.206 (talk) 09:13, 22 May 2017 (UTC)

Germany had at least two legal homosexual megazinea that where publish under kaiser Willhelm
Hitler's was not afraid to change history to suite his own history of Germany like things he did on Fredrick the great and others

Lack of sources
"The Committee also assisted defendants in criminal trials, conducted public lectures, and gathered signatures on a petition for the repeal of the law. Signatories included Albert Einstein, Hermann Hesse, Thomas Mann, Rainer Maria Rilke, and Leo Tolstoy. "

I think this paragraph is very interesting, however it lacks references. I've looked on the German version of this article and I didn't found the paragraph neither, of course, the reference.

I was able to find other articles on the internet stating a similar information, but without reputable references as well. If someone knows better where to look its reference up, I think it would be worthwhile adding it. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Januoaxe (talk • contribs) 16:04, 22 August 2016 (UTC)

New Source
I noticed a couple minor issues with this article. All proposed changes below are proposed based on information from Magnus Hirschfeld: The Origins of the Gay Liberation Movement, a university publication that contains a lot of information on the topic.

"Although it never had more than 500 members..." According to the source I was looking at, the committee capped out at nearly 700 members in its heyday. Additionally, the "Publications" section makes no mention of the committee's informative brochure, What Must Our Nation Know of the Third Sex?.

I intend to just make a few minor changes to add clarity and information on those two points. If anyone has any comments about this, please let me know either here or on my talk page! I'm very open to suggestions.

JTatreau (talk) 20:51, 11 May 2021 (UTC)

4 Top Nazi Leaders from 1938-1945 on this subject
1-"Hitler, #2-Himmler, #3- Goring, #4- Prague Preparer (Hitler's Favorite) ASSASINATED BY FRENCH Troops but died later on not too long Hitler murdered whole towns for his tragic painful death that he deserved in gods name Amen! On Judgement Day look for these 4 Bad Angels of Death at the Forefront! ALBERT SPEERS SAID at his interview after his trial +20 year mandantory sentence! Also stated that Starduct Camps were totally changed before his arrivals and after his departure! That Spared him CIA had Proof plus he had Relatives 1st Blood Dads side in Dayton Ky USA from early 20s to 1960s. Speers Hospital my mom, dad, aunts uncles both sides were all born there i was 1st offspring born from both parents siblings at St. Luke 1968. Speers also stated he would be on Gods Side hopefully with his idol Arc Angel Michael. Studied Michaelangelo like he was immulating his devine instruction thought Nazis were smart until Slums opened up for Jews cuz Himmler lied for Hitler and told Speers that they were Enemy POW Slave Camps! My 7th Great Grandpa was from Hanover and 7th great grandma was from Danzig but married and left for New World because The Great was coming down hard on Catholics so they left Prussia which is NOW present day Germany and Poland. My 7th great grandpa was the Revolutionary Wars Longest Tenure Easily by Month's. He knew Roman German Catholic was the Only Way for THEM. (Prussian German Latin Spoke Mass's Catholic's) Brought Ar hitects from Prussia also to Build Worlds Top Churches in the USA. Cincinnati tri state Area Huge German influence and even spoke German until 1960s in mass and schools. Lookinatlucky859 (talk) 09:06, 7 October 2021 (UTC)

Many facts appear to be missing
This page is interesting (as is a page it links to about Hirschfeld).

Interesting because of what the pages haven't mentioned. Their page on the clinic omits the fact that one surgeon was Erwin Gohrbandt, a psychopath who went on to experiment on captives of the Nazi concentration camps.

Magnus Hirschfeld championed eugenics.

In 1931 he visited Paul Popenoe and Ezra Gosney in America, fellow champions of sterilisation for the “feeble-minded”. He was apparently greeted “like an old friend… we have studied for 25 years”. Both men were racists and white supremacists.

Hirschfield praised them as being in “the vanguard of improving humanity by sterilising unfit men and women”. Their research was to provide the model for the introduction of the Nazis’ compulsory sterilisation program just two years later in 1933. He encouraged voluntary sterilisation and castration, particularly for gay men. He was also open to forced sterilisations for the ‘feeble-minded’ and oversexed, as well as the disabled. Why are these matters missing from the page on Hirschfeld and this page on his institution? Surely they're essential in creating a full picture of things? Charliepenandink (talk) 01:45, 14 March 2024 (UTC)