Talk:Shilmani

Cleanup
I added the tag because this article needs a grammar check, structuring and wikification. Mgm|(talk) 15:53, Jan 2, 2005 (UTC)

Vandalism and Plagiarism in Shalmani Page
Information about Shalmani as "Tajik" is removed because;

Someone has added personal ideas to the research of an Indian Civil Service administrator H.A. Rose's work, so as to make himself as a familiar researcher/writer without any authentic sources of information or research done by own-self except Lieutenant Husbandman's reference.

This is a clear harassment of Shalmani tribe by this unknown username to call Shalmani as "Shalmani Tajik".

Although it is mentioned in the book " A Glossary of the Tribes and Castes of the Punjab and North-West ..., Volume 3 " that (...Shalmani, erroneously styled Dihgan....) but there is no any further research with evidence showing the fact that Shalmani are Tajik who are found in Tajikistan etc.

This unknown username is continuously calling Shalmani Pashtun tribe as "Shalmani Tajik" with no any historical book evidence. This is clear harassment of Shalmani tribe that someone is calling it as "Shalmani Tajik" and this is happened for the first time in the history after Lieutenant Husbandman's book.

It seems an act of vandalism and plagiarism which is used as harassment against a Pashtun tribe that speak Pashto and never speak Tajiki, Dari or Persian. No one has the right to name/label a tribe with whatever name/label he/she like for that tribe. Even Lieutenant Husbandman did not call Shalmani as "Shalmani Tajik" except few words and expressions to suggest that they could be of Tajik origin.

The removed text seems to be a copy paste work, as this text was found in an unfamiliar Pakistani website and someone has copied it and pasted into Shalmani page. Anyone can pay to a news paper in Pakistan and publish something against anyone.

Again this is a clear harassment of Shalmani tribe by this unknown username to call Shalmani as "Shalmani Tajik". famous name in Shalmanis are Saqib bashir Shalmani from Sakhakot

This act of vandalism and plagiarism shall be strictly condemned and restricted from further unprofessional modifications.

Shalmani Tribe is never found in Tajikistan and they never speak Tajik language anywhere in the world. Therefore a reference to Tajik would make Shalmani page more confusing who are clear Pashtun speaking pashto across the country (Pakistan) even in non pashtun areas like Haripur, Abbotabad and province of Sindh where they live since centuries and speak Pashto as their mother tongue. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 93.168.250.233 (talk) 19:48, 28 December 2017 (UTC)