Talk:Shrapnel Valley Cemetery

"Did you know" Wikipedia candidate and check list
Complies: article is NPOV and is in a different field of interest than other DYK listings Complies: Article is not trivial but a part of the second largest war in world history and also subject of a Mel Gibson film, Gallipoli. ''Complies: This article is less than 5 days old. It was created today.''
 * Please keep suggestions NPOV and attempt to have items from different fields of interest in an update.
 * For exact guidelines as to how to update see the Guide to Updating DYK (still a work in progress).
 * Administrators: when you add an image to DYK, it is automatically protected, so simply add an mprotected notice to the image description page (or C-uploaded if you have uploaded a temporary copy from Commons).
 * DYK is not a general trivia section.
 * DYK is only for articles that have been created within the last 5 days. Ideally, they should have been listed on "New Pages" during that time, but former redirects, stubs, or other short articles that have been greatly expanded are also encouraged (as a guideline, an expansion of five-fold or more is acceptable; the decision on whether an expanded article is appropriate for the template will depend on the updating administrator's judgment). For those workpages first developed in user space, the date the workpage is posted to article namespace may be counted as the first day towards the DYK 5 day rule. You may wish to consider adding workpage to the top of the workpage.

Selections
Comples: length is almost double the minimum length.
 * Articles should have a minimum of 1,500 characters of main body text in size, and preferably longer - no stubs.
 * Does not comply. It says 1,500 characters of main body text. At Template talk:Did you know, this is elaborated as follows: "contain more than 1,500 characters (around 1.5 kilobytes) in main body text (ignoring infoboxes, categories, references, lists, and tables)". Counted that way, I get 1,168 characters. Art LaPella 00:56, 8 October 2007 (UTC) Thank you.  I've added material which happens to make it comply now! Chergles 16:42, 8 October 2007 (UTC)

Complies: This article is related to World War I, which involved many countries. Complies: Several sources, this is notable since the war was 90 years ago, long before the internet era. ''Complies: I did not create this article. It does motivate editors to contribute. Look at me. I (Chergles) saw it and contributed.''
 * Try to pick articles that are original to Wikipedia (not 1911 or other data sources) and interesting to a wide audience.
 * The "Did you know?" fact must be mentioned in the article and preferably cited with an inline citation since inline citations are used to support specific statements in an article.
 * Try to avoid country-centrism and topic-centrism. Wikipedia is a general-interest encyclopedia with a global audience. No DYK installment should have more than two entries relating to one country, topic, or issue, and no more than one is even better.
 * Select articles which cite their sources. Uncited articles are unlikely to be chosen.
 * A suggestion rather than a rule: try to avoid picking your own suggestions. Use common sense here, and please avoid even the appearance of conflict of interest. DYK is meant to be something that is motivating to editors creating new content.
 * When you write the DYK item (or "hook") please make it "hooky", that is, short, punchy, catchy, and likely to draw the readers in to wanting to read the article. Shorter hooks are preferred to longer ones, as long as they don't misstate the article content.
 * Does not comply . It's longer than any hook you'll see accepted on the Main Page. At Template talk:Did you know, note my 316 character hook. link which elaborates on this routine problem. Art LaPella 00:56, 8 October 2007 (UTC) Thank you for your advice. Revising to comply. Chergles 16:42, 8 October 2007 (UTC)

Complies: It hasn't changed for 90 years, won't change for another 90 years. Chergles 23:19, 7 October 2007 (UTC)
 * The hook should refer to established facts that are not likely to change, and should be relevant for more than just novelty or newness.
 * Other editors may propose changes to the suggested hook as follow-ups.

Please make the article longer and the hook shorter. If the shortened hook still includes Gallipoli, the battle and the film, you or I should wikilink them. I added a link to Template talk:Did you know to Did you know, since you went to so much work to document our rules but missed some of our most regularly enforced ones. I also corrected details including the spelling of cemetery. "Did You Know" nitpicker Art LaPella 00:56, 8 October 2007 (UTC)

Thank you.

John Simpson Kirkpatrick's grave
Which "legend" is buried here? John Simpson Kirkpatrick and Beach Commonwealth War Graves Commission Cemetery says he is buried there. -- !! ?? 23:20, 12 October 2007 (UTC)

John Simpson Kirkpatrick is indeed buried at Beach Cemetery, Plot 1, Row F, Grave 1. The first reference, the Australian Government ANZAC website, quotes a letter saying he was killed in Shrapnel Gully. However the second one, the CWGC website, contradicts this by saying that he was killed near Steele's Post, which was on the front line at the top of Monash Valley. The main route from the beach area to the front line was through Shrapnel Gully and then through Monash Valley. -- Jll 21:28, 19 October 2007 (UTC)