Talk:Shylah Waikai

Notability clarification
PRehse we need to clarify this because i dont want to get into a issue thingy or what ever its called under WP:NBOX # 4 it states that:

4. Has fought, as an amateur, in the final of a national amateur championship for an International Boxing Association/Association Internationale de Boxe Amateur (AIBA) affiliated and World Amateur Boxing Championship medal winning country (for Men see Medal table (1974–present), for Women see Medal table (2001–present)), or have represented their AIBA affiliated country in a continental (or higher) tournament.

The Commonwealth Youth Games isn't only a higher version of a Continental winning tournament but it doesn't specify that it needs to be a non - youth competing competition. In saying that she has won a national amateur championship in New Zealand that is indeed affiliated with the International Boxing Association/Association Internationale de Boxe Amateur (AIBA). In saying that this notability is out of date and needs to be probably updated and clarified but this is what the notability states

If i am wrong please clearly show me exactly where it states that I am wrong --Bennyaha (talk) 00:44, 12 August 2017 (UTC)


 * Meant to answer this sooner. It was only a tag indicating an issue but if I was to  take it to AfD it would probably be deleted since age specific results consistently don't count towards notability. That has been true for boxers, martial artists, pretty much across the board.  I  would say the only reason it is  not mentioned in WP:NBOX is because it was always assumed.PRehse (talk) 11:07, 14 August 2017 (UTC)