Talk:Sikh terrorism

NPOV
Satanoid, it is quite clear that you have strong feelings on the subject of Sikhism. Although I'm not well-informed enough to provide a substantial counterargument, I think that, given your record, your article bears examination from other editors. C1k3 (talk) 11:59, 17 December 2008 (UTC)

Article name conceern
In deciding to change my vote against moving Sikh Extremism to this name, I was swayed by the argument that this title would be like Jewish Bankers or Christian Murderers... linking the group with an act is pejorative. There are terrorists of many sorts. Does each classification merit an article? No... and thus my no vote. sinneed (talk) 15:12, 17 December 2008 (UTC)
 * No vote: This article is yet again bad faith attempt by Satanoid; how far can assuming good faith be stretched seeing that so many editors have been kept busy in wasting time by this editor? S/he continues povforking content from already existing article Punjab Insurgency and Khalistan to appease some sort of hate that Satanoid seems to have against Sikhs. Once again, this is just plain hate driven wishful thinking. --Road Ahead  =Discuss= 17:42, 17 December 2008 (UTC)

Lead issue; again?
Satanoid!, we have been having a very long discussion since 22nd November 2008 on the talkpage of the similar article you created. You have once again started article with similar issues by content forking. I am reproducing the issue here: -
 * Lead is OR, makes extraordinary controversial claim but still no references provided Current lead says:- "Sikh terrorism is religious terrorism by groups or individuals, the motivation of which is typically rooted in an Sikh beliefs, principles and tenets"


 * 1) How was the term “Sikh terrorism” coined and where is this definition published?
 * 2) Who linked the term “Sikh terrorism” to “religious terrorism”
 * 3) Where is the research from a peer reviewed highly cited work that tells that the "motivation" of this so called “Sikh terrorism” (which the contributor equated to “religious terrorism”)  “is typically rooted in an Sikh beliefs, principles and tenets”? In fact, this is a super extraordinary claim. Wikipedia says, “extraordinary claims will need extraordinary evidence”. Not surprisingly, the contributor still found it all right to not provide even a single source, leave aside it being reliable and extra-ordinary. --Road Ahead  =Discuss= 18:43, 17 December 2008 (UTC)

Redirect back to Sikh extremism
I've converted the POV fork back into a redirect. If you don't get it renamed and you lose out on the lead, you don't get to create a new article until you get what you want. -- Ricky81682 (talk) 19:02, 17 December 2008 (UTC)