Talk:Steven the Sword Fighter

Notable?
I have some concerns that this episode may fail WP:GNG, like other articles about episodes of Steven Universe. With most of its content sourced to Tumblr, and few mentions in reliable secondary sources, I was inclined to nominate it for deletion (just like this and this). Just wondering what anyone (especially you,, as the GA reviewer) thinks. Thanks —  Quasar  G.  12:18, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
 * So this was the first GA nom I ever did, and so I may not have done a sufficient job. Notability is not a GA criterion but I did believe at the time that the article was notable. Tumblr is fine as a primary source but of course doesn't establish notability; the reason I thought it is notable is these sources: (especially the AV source). I feel I should point out that  (article creator, GA nominator) did have some notability concerns themselves (see Special:Diff/605375353).  in 2014 you seemed to believe the Steven Universe episode articles were notable in 2014 here; is this still your opinion? As for my current opinion, I believe this episode is just about notable, and would vote keep in an AfD (not that that should stop you nominating it if you believe it fails GNG), but I'm not too sure it should be a GA so I would probably abstain if you nominated it at WP:GAR. — Bilorv(talk)(c)(e) 16:10, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
 * re the sources you mentioned, they all seem a little too blog-ish to me; the AV club one is the best but every episode has an article so it doesn't prove that this episode is particularly special. I'm not sure myself if this passes the GNG, and would probably vote weak delete in an AfD, if I were not the nominator. Hence, I will nominate it to gain further consensus. —  Quasar   G.  16:59, 10 June 2017 (UTC)
 * AV Club and Cartoon Brew have passed muster in other articles, as while "blogs" they have editorial oversight, which is a cornerstone of reliability. However, about 90% of this article is source to Tumblr, which is a bit too WP:PRIMARY. Ten Pound Hammer • (What did I screw up now?) 01:12, 11 June 2017 (UTC)