Talk:Swordmasters of the Ginaz

Untitled
I do not quite understand how someone without logging in and without any comment could go ahead and delete a whole paragraph from an entry.(The last part about the end of House Ginaz removed 02:20, 15 March 2006 by 70.238.105.73) Admittedly, this last paragraph is based on material from the Dune Encyclopedia which many do not consider canonical. Still, if that were the case i would at least expect this to be given as a reason. Since i see no reason why this deletion should happen, i have put that paragraph back in. Conosphaera 23:46, 28 July 2006 (UTC)


 * thanks for the re-addition. -- maxrspct  in the mud  23:48, 28 July 2006 (UTC)

Gwendelin Ana
I can find no mention of this person in the final paragraph anywhere in any Dune-related material, and the style of the writing is noticably different from the remainder of the article. Where does this personage come from? Dune itself makes no mention of the name of any of Stilgar's girlfriends, wives, or paramours, and most certainly does not express one of them being any kind of swordmaster. I am removing this section as it is totally unverifiable without an explicit source. Zakath 03:52, 28 October 2006 (UTC)

Prequel Bias
Hi, I'm not opening a discussion on the merits or otherwise of the prequels here but I feel this article relies too heavily on the descriptions from the prequel material without reference to the original novels. My one issue is this: where is Gamont mentioned in this whole article? Nowhere. This is particularly odd. I want to raise this in Talk before editing the article appropriately. What are your thoughts? I feel Gamont should at least be mentioned. Coldmachine 10:59, 3 May 2007 (UTC)