Talk:The Great God Pan (sculpture)

Draft by User:ColumbiaArtHum
The Great God Pan is a sculpture on the Lewisohn Lawn at Columbia University in New York City. It was crafted by George Grey Barnard (1863 – 1938) in 1899. The sculpture was commissioned in 1895 by Alfred Corning Clark and gifted by Edward Severin Clark to Columbia in 1907. Pan weighs more than three tons altogether with its granite plinth base. The bronze statue, approximately 4 ft. 1 in. x 9 ft. 1 1/2 in. x 3 ft 7 in, depicts [[Pan (mythology), the pagan nature god, who is half-goat and half-man. Pan reclines on his side on a rock, playing a pipe held by his right hand, as he is propped on his left arm; his left leg hangs loose on the granite base and the right leg is bent behind him. The bronze statue was designed to be a fountain, which is why it is supported by a granite pedestal decorated in front with three lion-head water spouts.

For much of his early career, Barnard had been supported by his generous patron, Alfred Corning Clark, the son and heir of a founder of the Singer Corporation. In 1894, he was finishing his marble statue “The Two Natures” and began thinking about his new project. In a January 14 letter to his parents, he wrote “I have been busy this last week on a study for the old God Pan, down by the river playing his reed – I am in hopes of selling this one to young Edward Severin Clark for the entrance to the Dakota.” Edward Severin Clark was the eldest son of Alfred Corning Clark. Barnard had envisioned the Pan to be in the courtyard of The Dakota, a property of the Clarks at 72nd Street (Manhattan) and Central Park West -- Manhattan’s first luxury apartment building. In 1895, Alfred Corning Clark commissioned Barnard to create the sculpture for a fountain at the Dakota.
 * Commissioning Information

Barnard’s Pan is the first use of classical mythology by the sculptor. Several explanations exist as to why Barnard decided to create this mythical beast. The sculptor’s concept seems to be inspired by Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s poem A Musical Instrument, in which she writes “What was he doing, the great god Pan/ Down in the reeds by the river?/ Splashing and paddling with hoofs of a goat.” Indeed, Browning’s god Pan matches that of Barnard’s, as a lumbering beastly creature. When the Pan sculpture was finished, Browning’s poem was often cited as a literary parallel. The artistic ancestry of Pan appears to come from Michelangelo, Barnard’s idol. In Pan, commentators quickly found references to Michelangelo’s Medici tomb sculptures.
 * Iconography

In 1898 Pan was cast into bronze as the largest bronze statue ever cast in one piece in the United States. The casting was hailed as a triumph of American industry over their European counterparts that had been unwilling to take on the formidable task of casting Pan in one piece, a request made by Barnard himself. After several European foundries declined, Henry Bonnard Bronze Company was commissioned to do the casting. The company saw Pan as a special challenge and spent most of a year doing preparatory work. Some 27 tons of outer mold, in sections weighing 4-5 tons each, and 1,700 pieces were involved in constructing the mold and its core. In August 1898, the casting was carried out and resulted in a perfect cast.
 * Construction and Controversy

After the casting of Pan was complete, it was soon to be unveiled in Central Park. However, American aversion at that time to the exposure of flesh in public places created several obstacles to the placement of Pan. Alfred Corning Clark, Barnard’s benefactor, died in 1896. With his death, Barnard was deprived of a patron who for a decade had been nearly his sole source of income. In settling the estate, the Clarks presented the two largest Barnard statues (The Two Natures and Pan) to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the City of New York. The Met accepted The Two Natures and it has been in the museum ever since. The donors presented Pan to the City in November of 1896 in hopes of finding a suitable location in Central Park for the statue. The inclination of public prudery at the time did not bode well for the Pan. After a long delay, in March 1887, Samuel Parsons, Superintendent of Parks, wrote Edward Severin Clark to let him know that he had been unable to find a proper site for Pan and thus would not be able to accept the statue. In following summer, several sites were proposed for Pan: General Collins, Commissioner of the Department of Public Works, saw no taint of vulgarity in the statue and proposed the entrance of the boulevard at Fifty-ninth Street; Mayor William L. Strong approved of finding an outdoor home for the work; another board member thought Pan to be better suited for a museum. By this time, Pan had become a national sensation, either defended or opposed. A New Bedford, Massachusetts editor wrote, “It is a rather singular idea to put this pagan symbol in a public place in a Christian country.” Barnard himself filled over forty pages of his scrapbook with news clippings and cartoons of the statue. Vogue, Independent, Bookman and others all published features on Pan. In the end, no home was found for Pan; after its casting, the statue lay hidden away until the Clarks gave it to Columbia in 1907.

The Great God Pan is made of bronze with a polished green granite plinth base. In April of 1994, the statue underwent major conservation work for the first time. Over the years, the statue’s exposure to the elements corroded the work, causing some areas to turn green and others to turn black. The two-toned corrosion led to stripes running down many parts of the statue. Joseph Sembrat Jr., a graduate of the Preservation Program in the Architecture School, led conservation efforts. Treatment of Pan included “the stripping of all old wax, applying a chemical patina, and then rewaxing – in order to stabilize the metal against further corrosion and to unify the color by toning down the streakiness.” The conservation work began on April 18, 1994 and was monitored by Professor Martin Weaver, director of Columbia’s Center for Preservation Research, and his preservation class. Prior to the main restoration work in 1994, Columbia obtained examination reports and treatment recommendations from several conservators. The consensus of these reports was that both the statue and pedestal were in fair to poor condition. In July of 1983, an examination report done by Art Properties states that “the piece is badly corroded and pitted overall.” At the time, there were numerous accretions on the statue: tar in his eyes, on his buttocks, and in his hair. There was also corrosive substance below his mouth that caused a blue residue. As part of a new project to wash and wax the sculpture annually (by Columbia’s groundskeeper), the accretions were removed using acetone, methyl cloride, and mechanically with a wooden splint and scalpel. The statue was then washed, rinsed, and waxed.
 * Restoration History

Since its arrival on Columbia’s campus, Pan has moved around several times due to construction. Upon its arrival in 1907, it was agreed that Pan should be placed on The Green, at the northerly end of campus; its original home was a custom-made pool in the northeast corner of campus, on Amsterdam Avenue and 120th Street, where Mudd Hall currently is. In 1959, Pan had to be moved to make room for the new engineering building. In September of 1962 the Trustees Committee on Buildings and Grounds approved the recommendation that Pan be placed in the center of the Avery – Faverweather quadrangle on the west side with its back against Avery and facing Fayerweather minus his pool. Some were upset by the pagan god being placed in close proximity to the Chapel. In 1975, due to the construction of Avery Extentsion, Pan was moved from Fayerweather to its current location in the Lewisohn quad.
 * Location on Campus

At the end of the nineteenth century, when news spread that New York had rejected the Pan, other cities quickly made known their willingness to accept the statue. Newark, Syracuse, Denver, and St. Louis all had places ready for it. However, the Clarks made clear their desire for the statue to stay in New York. On August 26, 1969, the Bellefonte (Pennsylvania – Barnard’s birthplace) Area Chamber of Commerce wrote a letter to the President of Columbia, inquiring about the statue’s availability to an interested participant. Bellefonte was keenly interested in the statue as the town hoped to obtain a work by its native artist. However, by this time, Columbia had already moved Pan to its new location and decided that it added greatly to the amenity of campus and would not be sold.
 * Possible Relocation to Other Cities


 * Exhibitions
 * Bronze cast never exhibited except at Columbia University
 * Plaster cast
 * Barnard’s original one-man exhibition. November 1898. Logerot Garden, New York City
 * Paris Exposition, 1900 (Exposition Universelle (1900)). Winner of the gold medal
 * Exhibited at entrance of the Fine Arts Building of the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo, 1901. Received gold medal
 * Joint exhibition by the National Sculpture Society and the New York Florists Club, Madison Square Garden, New York, Fall 1902.
 * Louisiana Purchase Exposition, St. Louis, 1904.
 * One-man exhibition of Barnard’s work, Boston, MA, 1908.


 * Inscriptions
 * Rear near plinth: "Geo. Gray Barnard Sculptor. 1899"
 * Proper left near plinth: "Cast in One Piece by the Henry Bonnard Bronze Co. New. -Y- 1899."


 * Further Reading
 * Harold E. Dickson, “The Other Orphan”, American Art Journal, Vol. 1, No. 2 (Autumn 1969), p. 108-118.
 * “The Repatination of Pan.” The Record, April 29, 1994, Vol 19, No 26.

-- Another Believer ( Talk ) 17:26, 19 June 2014 (UTC)

Map of Columbia University
Anyone know how to replace the infobox map of Manhattan with one of Columbia University? I think the smaller area would be more helpful. --- Another Believer ( Talk ) 21:13, 19 November 2019 (UTC)
 * You've helped with map creations before. I'm wondering if you might be willing to create one for Columbia University? Either way, happy editing! --- Another Believer ( Talk ) 15:58, 4 December 2019 (UTC)

Good article?
Thanks again for your work on this article. Curious, do you think you're getting close to nominating for Good article status? I'm tempted to at least bump to B-class for now. --- Another Believer ( Talk ) 15:59, 4 December 2019 (UTC)
 * I'm awaiting the arrival of a used book I ordered on Monday. It contains Barnard's descriptions of the urn's figure groups, so I'm hoping important info is forthcoming. == BoringHistoryGuy (talk) 16:09, 4 December 2019 (UTC)
 * , Wonderful! Looking forward to your final improvements to this entry. --- Another Believer ( Talk ) 16:11, 4 December 2019 (UTC)
 * Okay, I'm all mixed up. The book describes the Urn of Life, not Pan. (Working on too many articles at once.) == BoringHistoryGuy (talk) 16:16, 4 December 2019 (UTC)
 * All good! I've updated the article to B-class for now. --- Another Believer ( Talk ) 17:23, 5 December 2019 (UTC)
 * With just a bit of lead expansion, this article might meet GA criteria. I've also requested a copy edit from the Guild of Copy Editors, not because I see poorly written prose but because I do this before possible GA noms and find the process generally helpful. --- Another Believer ( Talk ) 17:50, 30 December 2019 (UTC)
 * I did a bit of cleanup and left two hidden comments in the article. – Jonesey95 (talk) 07:44, 31 December 2019 (UTC)
 * , Thanks! --- Another Believer ( Talk ) 19:02, 31 December 2019 (UTC)